Quizzes & Puzzles10 mins ago
Finding Out What A Painting Might Be Worth
13 Answers
Why is it so difficult to find out what a painting by an artist might be worth?
I realise it’s a living, but to register with various websites to enable you to see auction prices are mostly in three figures.
I was looking up an artist called, Wm Milne.
I realise it’s a living, but to register with various websites to enable you to see auction prices are mostly in three figures.
I was looking up an artist called, Wm Milne.
Answers
1 to 13 of 13
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by chrissa1. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Tayler & Fletcher
Lot 437
William Milne (1864-1949), a gilt framed Oil on Canvas "Scottish Fisherman", signed and dated 1906, prevalent horizontal paint cracking to top of painting, 24.5cm x 34.5cm CONDITION REPORT: Prevalent horizontal paint cracking to the top of the painting, there are several cracked areas, horizontal to the paintwork, lots of “star cracks” and other cracking and damage to the paint surface that is identified in the images taken.
300-500
Lot 437
William Milne (1864-1949), a gilt framed Oil on Canvas "Scottish Fisherman", signed and dated 1906, prevalent horizontal paint cracking to top of painting, 24.5cm x 34.5cm CONDITION REPORT: Prevalent horizontal paint cracking to the top of the painting, there are several cracked areas, horizontal to the paintwork, lots of “star cracks” and other cracking and damage to the paint surface that is identified in the images taken.
300-500
Almost every fine art auctioneer will give you a valuation free of charge. (Of course they're hoping that you'll sell through their auction house but there's no commitment involved. I've taken items into Bonham's in London, with no appointment, and asked for valuations on them. Within minutes I was seen by the same guy that people queue for hours to see on the Antiques Roadshow).
However, assuming that the 'Wm Milne' in question is the Edinburgh artist of that name, this gallery is asking £3500 for one of his works:
http://
That doesn't mean that anyone will be prepared to pay that though. I note, as well, that the provenance for the work is given as 'Christies'. That suggests that the gallery which is now offering the painting for sale might well have bought it there. Knowing the types of mark-up that galleries aim for, I'd guess that they would have only paid between £1000 and £2000 for it, so that might offer some sort of guidance as to what you could get at auction. (You'd then need to deduct the auctioneer's hefty commission from that figure, together with the VAT on the commission, perhaps leaving you with between £800 and £1600).
Those figures should only be used as VERY rough guides though, as the theme of a painting, its condition, its size and whether it's an early or late work by the artist can all make a big difference to its value.
As I've suggested already, take it to a reputable fine art auction house (not a general auction room) and ask for an estimate. Most auction rooms don't make any charge. (The only exception to that is if you require a formal written estimate for insurance purposes).
However, assuming that the 'Wm Milne' in question is the Edinburgh artist of that name, this gallery is asking £3500 for one of his works:
http://
That doesn't mean that anyone will be prepared to pay that though. I note, as well, that the provenance for the work is given as 'Christies'. That suggests that the gallery which is now offering the painting for sale might well have bought it there. Knowing the types of mark-up that galleries aim for, I'd guess that they would have only paid between £1000 and £2000 for it, so that might offer some sort of guidance as to what you could get at auction. (You'd then need to deduct the auctioneer's hefty commission from that figure, together with the VAT on the commission, perhaps leaving you with between £800 and £1600).
Those figures should only be used as VERY rough guides though, as the theme of a painting, its condition, its size and whether it's an early or late work by the artist can all make a big difference to its value.
As I've suggested already, take it to a reputable fine art auction house (not a general auction room) and ask for an estimate. Most auction rooms don't make any charge. (The only exception to that is if you require a formal written estimate for insurance purposes).
https:/
william colne milne - £520 in Scarborough
william colne milne - £520 in Scarborough
william watt milne did paint in Cornwall such as this.... http://
1 to 13 of 13
Latest Posts
ChatterBank23 mins ago
Quizzes & Puzzles26 mins ago
Food & Drink32 mins ago
ChatterBank68 mins ago
Quizzes & Puzzles72 mins ago
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.