This has been ongoing for five years? This means that the debt has been 'sold on' to various collection agencies. You don't own them anything. The original debt was to the bank and they've given up on collecting it and sold it on to the various agencies. See my other answer re deceased credit card debt. The agencies will continue to chase you as long as you reply/try to negotiate with them. Don't they know there's a credit crunch? Tell 'em to go away. Or, better yet, totally ignore them. If they knock your door tell them you don't know what they're taking about. They will eventually give up. Don't forget, they are all insured for bad debt. In fact, they get tax relief on it! I hate the fact that these companies harass people - you can't get blood out of a stone.....