Quizzes & Puzzles0 min ago
Ruling Against A Liar
10 Answers
Dont know how to word this question but here goes.
My husband and me were involved in a car accident where someone hit us and we were shunted into someone else.
He's now been to one of those 'no win, no fee' lawyers saying no only he was in the car but 2 others were in it and were hurt.
We can honestly say there was no one else there! But he's taking it to the Magistrates Court.
So what will happen if he gets found to be a liar? (Which he is) will he just be just refused the compo he is after or will he get some sort of punishment?
My husband and me were involved in a car accident where someone hit us and we were shunted into someone else.
He's now been to one of those 'no win, no fee' lawyers saying no only he was in the car but 2 others were in it and were hurt.
We can honestly say there was no one else there! But he's taking it to the Magistrates Court.
So what will happen if he gets found to be a liar? (Which he is) will he just be just refused the compo he is after or will he get some sort of punishment?
Answers
1 to 10 of 10
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by DarceyK123. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Magistrates' Courts only deal with criminal cases. (OK, there are a few exceptions to that statement but they're not relevant here). If the matter goes to court, it will be a County Court that hears the case.
Cases in the County Court are decided upon a 'balance of probabilities' basis. (i.e. neither side is required to prove their case beyond doubt. The judge simply has to decide which side's version of events is most likely to be true).
It's not clear from your post whether it's the driver of the car that hit yours who's seeking to initiate court action against you or the driver of the car that your vehicle was then pushed into. From your account of the accident though, it's hard to see how either of them could convince a court that they (and/or their passengers, fictitious or otherwise) suffered injury through any form of negligence on your part. So I find it hard to see how they could win their case.
If the judge ruled against them though, it wouldn't actually be proof that they were lying; it would simply mean that he thought that your version of events was most likely to be the true one. So there could be no 'punishment' for lying involved.
It's only in extremely rare situations, where it can be proved that a person who initiated court action was lying, that 'punishment' could come into play. However that punishment wouldn't come from the County Court judge; it would require a successful criminal prosecution for perjury and/or for 'attempting to pervert the course of justice' in order for such punishment to be meted out.
For example, Jeffrey Archer launched, and won, a libel case against the Daily Star. However he was later proved to have lied in that court case, resulting in him being convicted of both perjury and perverting the course of justice and sentenced to four years' imprisonment.
As I've said though, such cases are extremely rare. Vast numbers of people lie in court every day but hardly any are ever prosecuted for it.
Cases in the County Court are decided upon a 'balance of probabilities' basis. (i.e. neither side is required to prove their case beyond doubt. The judge simply has to decide which side's version of events is most likely to be true).
It's not clear from your post whether it's the driver of the car that hit yours who's seeking to initiate court action against you or the driver of the car that your vehicle was then pushed into. From your account of the accident though, it's hard to see how either of them could convince a court that they (and/or their passengers, fictitious or otherwise) suffered injury through any form of negligence on your part. So I find it hard to see how they could win their case.
If the judge ruled against them though, it wouldn't actually be proof that they were lying; it would simply mean that he thought that your version of events was most likely to be the true one. So there could be no 'punishment' for lying involved.
It's only in extremely rare situations, where it can be proved that a person who initiated court action was lying, that 'punishment' could come into play. However that punishment wouldn't come from the County Court judge; it would require a successful criminal prosecution for perjury and/or for 'attempting to pervert the course of justice' in order for such punishment to be meted out.
For example, Jeffrey Archer launched, and won, a libel case against the Daily Star. However he was later proved to have lied in that court case, resulting in him being convicted of both perjury and perverting the course of justice and sentenced to four years' imprisonment.
As I've said though, such cases are extremely rare. Vast numbers of people lie in court every day but hardly any are ever prosecuted for it.
How will he be found out to be a liar ? Is there video evidence ?
A few years back someone ran a red light wrote off my car. It finally went to court and the judge ruled that on the basis of probability the victim was to blame and the perpetrator was innocent. I'm trying to forget it but you never know what can happen.
A few years back someone ran a red light wrote off my car. It finally went to court and the judge ruled that on the basis of probability the victim was to blame and the perpetrator was innocent. I'm trying to forget it but you never know what can happen.
Thanks for your replies, the insurance companies are sorting it out but im going to the Court to give evidence as i dont agree with Insurance Companies being ripped off and raising our premiums. I have nothing to gain myself so dont have to go.
So really he has nothing to lose? If he gets the compensation its great, if not it was worth a try in his eyes.
Oh i hate scammers!! Grrr!
So really he has nothing to lose? If he gets the compensation its great, if not it was worth a try in his eyes.
Oh i hate scammers!! Grrr!
I don't understand your post, douglas. This is the sort of false compensation claim I referred to https:/
1 to 10 of 10
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.