Can You See Any Issues With Buying This...
Home & Garden2 mins ago
Jury service, staying in hotels and discussing the case.
Have watched the BBC1 programme tonight about the conviction and new evidence found in the case of the killer of Jill Dando I was struck by one point that was being made.
The trail had lasted 8 weeks and on the final weekend (Saturday) the jury were sent to a hotel until Monday. But were ordered not to discuss the trail with other jurors. Why? They've sat there through the whole trail, so why not discuss it with each other jury members.
Also, when the jury are trying to reach a verdict in the court building then whole else is present, other than the 12 jury members? And if there is someone what is there role?
The trail had lasted 8 weeks and on the final weekend (Saturday) the jury were sent to a hotel until Monday. But were ordered not to discuss the trail with other jurors. Why? They've sat there through the whole trail, so why not discuss it with each other jury members.
Also, when the jury are trying to reach a verdict in the court building then whole else is present, other than the 12 jury members? And if there is someone what is there role?
Answers
1 to 2 of 2
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by spainlads. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Q1: "Why? They've sat there through the whole trail, so why not discuss it with each other jury members."
A1: Let's suppose that Alf and Mary are both members of the jury. They have a quiet drink together at the hotel. Alf states why he thinks that the defendant is, in his opinion, guilty. Mary listens and finds herself agreeing. By the end of the conversation, they've both become convinced of the defendant's guilt and they're unlikely to change their minds.
Now let's suppose that, instead of having that conversation over a drink, they have it in the jury room. Alf puts forward his arguments. Mary is about to agree but another juror, Dave, says "Hang on a minute, what about the evidence of Mr Bloggs?". Ethel now joins in: "Yes, I think that's very important". Now Alf and Mary are forced to listen to counter-arguments before reaching their conclusions. i.e. it's of paramount importance that EVERY juror must listen to the views of ALL the other jurors before reaching their decision.
Q2: "Also, when the jury are trying to reach a verdict in the court building then whole else is present, other than the 12 jury members? And if there is someone what is there role?"
A2: Jurors always discuss a case in private. However, they're able to call upon the services of a court official who can, for example, pass a note to the judge seeking legal guidance for the jury. Normally, however, the sole function of the court official is to inform the judge when the jury are ready to return to the courtroom.
Chris
A1: Let's suppose that Alf and Mary are both members of the jury. They have a quiet drink together at the hotel. Alf states why he thinks that the defendant is, in his opinion, guilty. Mary listens and finds herself agreeing. By the end of the conversation, they've both become convinced of the defendant's guilt and they're unlikely to change their minds.
Now let's suppose that, instead of having that conversation over a drink, they have it in the jury room. Alf puts forward his arguments. Mary is about to agree but another juror, Dave, says "Hang on a minute, what about the evidence of Mr Bloggs?". Ethel now joins in: "Yes, I think that's very important". Now Alf and Mary are forced to listen to counter-arguments before reaching their conclusions. i.e. it's of paramount importance that EVERY juror must listen to the views of ALL the other jurors before reaching their decision.
Q2: "Also, when the jury are trying to reach a verdict in the court building then whole else is present, other than the 12 jury members? And if there is someone what is there role?"
A2: Jurors always discuss a case in private. However, they're able to call upon the services of a court official who can, for example, pass a note to the judge seeking legal guidance for the jury. Normally, however, the sole function of the court official is to inform the judge when the jury are ready to return to the courtroom.
Chris
1 to 2 of 2
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.