News0 min ago
Anonymous information, protected witnesses
In light of the Liverpool shooting, if someone volunteers definite evidence to the police sufficient to support a prosecution, how does it work ? It is necessary that the defendant and his mates don't get to know who shopped him, so he and his defence are faced with fighting an unknown witness. Does the prosecution secretly reveal the identity and the power of the evidence to the defence counsel ?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by whiffey. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
-- answer removed --
Actually, just to clarify Inapickle's answer, the defence lawyer does not have to be told of the persons identity, only the judge must be satisfied that the witness is bona fide. This is what happens with paid police informers, their details are normally never released to the defence even if they provide good evidence. A statement is not taken from the informer but their 'handler' provides a document outlining the information that they can provide. This normally means that the informer is not a proper witness as such and therefore does not get called to trial.
If the informer does provide a statement and is called to court, they will be given a false name for court purposes ie "Dave" and their identify and possibly even real voice concealed.
If the prosecution were ever to 'secretly reveal' informers details to the defence then it would a) completely undermine the reason for having informers in the first place and b) put the informer at risk of harm (not all solicitors are honest!).
Finally, it's worth saying that if you do know anything that would assist the police in the investigation into the murder of this poor child, you should help all you can.
If the informer does provide a statement and is called to court, they will be given a false name for court purposes ie "Dave" and their identify and possibly even real voice concealed.
If the prosecution were ever to 'secretly reveal' informers details to the defence then it would a) completely undermine the reason for having informers in the first place and b) put the informer at risk of harm (not all solicitors are honest!).
Finally, it's worth saying that if you do know anything that would assist the police in the investigation into the murder of this poor child, you should help all you can.
-- answer removed --
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.