News2 mins ago
Genes Reunited and the Data Protection Act
Some of my own details have been entered by a relative on Genes Reunited without my consent and these have then been copied by others.
Does this contravene the Data Protection Act in any way?
Does this contravene the Data Protection Act in any way?
Answers
IF there is a breach of the Data Protection Act (and I'm not convinced there is) then it's your relative that has committed the breach
Genes Unlimited would only have committed a breach if you asked them to remove the information and they refused to do so without good reason - eg it's public domain data anyway.
10:19 Sun 06th Feb 2011
IF there is a breach of the Data Protection Act (and I'm not convinced there is) then it's your relative that has committed the breach
Genes Unlimited would only have committed a breach if you asked them to remove the information and they refused to do so without good reason - eg it's public domain data anyway.
Genes Unlimited would only have committed a breach if you asked them to remove the information and they refused to do so without good reason - eg it's public domain data anyway.
Craft1948 - Yes that is correct and those others are then giving are giving their trees even wider access.
4getmeknot - with respect I think that is beside the point. If I want to keep my family life to myself I don't see why details of me and living members of my family should be made widely available to others without my/our consent
Scotman - The relatives thought they knew the details but they contain errors.
Thank you all including dzug2 for your comments.
4getmeknot - with respect I think that is beside the point. If I want to keep my family life to myself I don't see why details of me and living members of my family should be made widely available to others without my/our consent
Scotman - The relatives thought they knew the details but they contain errors.
Thank you all including dzug2 for your comments.
Twix 123- Thanks for your comment. The point is I haven't shared my tree with anyone. My details (or what they thought were my details) have been entered by a relative on their tree and this has been shared with others on whose trees my details have also been entered. They also have entered details of other living relatives of mine who are not even users of Genes Reunited.
The data being made available on Genes Reunited (date of birth, name, etc) is likely already in the public domain and hence is not covered by the data protection act.
I could for example search the electoral role and find the same information about you.
Relationships between your relatives are also likely to available to the public already were to spend time searching for birth/death/marriage certificates.
Assuming that the information was not in the public domain and was covered by the data protection act there may well be a breach, but this breach would not be by genes reunited as they did not make the data available. The data has been made available by the person (or persons) who uploaded it to the genes reunited site and told the site to make it available to others.
I don't think the data protection act is being contravened in any way.
I could for example search the electoral role and find the same information about you.
Relationships between your relatives are also likely to available to the public already were to spend time searching for birth/death/marriage certificates.
Assuming that the information was not in the public domain and was covered by the data protection act there may well be a breach, but this breach would not be by genes reunited as they did not make the data available. The data has been made available by the person (or persons) who uploaded it to the genes reunited site and told the site to make it available to others.
I don't think the data protection act is being contravened in any way.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.