Ok, all from their prime and none from the original-
Christian Bale, Aidan Quinn, Brad Pitt, Gregory Peck, Lou Diamond Phillips, Rob Lowe and Keanu Reeves for the young hot-head one that stayed in the village.
excellent, don't like Keanu much but he would be good as the not too verbose one.. so in their prime
I would go with
Clint Eastwood
Gary Cooper
Errol Flynn
Paul Newman
Alan Ladd
Harrison Ford
Jimmy Stewart
Clint Eastwood, Kirk Douglas, Robert Redford, Gregory Peck, Pete Duel, Sean Connery and Bill Nighy - hahahahaha - still like the original line up though.
Sam Worthington (Avatar and Battleship) would def be on my list. Along with Will Smith, Heath Ledger, Orlando Bloom, Bill Pullman, Jason Statham and Jean Claude van Damm
OMG owd I can't see those two on horseback for long.
I would have George Clooney, Robert Redford, Hugh Jackman, Sean Connery,
Brad Pitt, Pierce Brosnan and Clive Owen.