Hmmm, I'm torn too between Colin Baker and Sylvester McCoy. I'd need to watch a couple of episodes with each but couldn't bring myself to do it so will settle with McCoy.
McCoy for me too.
I read in today's metro that he was trying to do the best with not a lot of support from the beeb who had lost interest in Dr Who.
After Mr McCoy, I'm surprised others have returned to watching it (me included)
Also, I've head Matt Smith being likened to an Easter Island Head, no comment
other than I like the comparison.