Andrew Neal On Newsnight 19/9

[tiggerblue10]

I was watching Newsnight last night and I felt that Andrew Neal was very rude the the first guest in the studio. Can't remember who he was but I think he may have been an MP and the discussion was following on from the Scottish referendum and regarding English MPs and devolution.

Did anyone else see this? What did you think?

[-Talbot-]

I didn't but agree he can be very rude (I love it though)

[brainiac]

The MP was Chuka Umuna. Good for Neil - polititians shouldn't be allowed to get away with their usual waffling

[-Talbot-]

Love this

http://www.theguardian.com/media/2013/jun/09/andrew-neil-alex-jones-sunday-politics

[tiggerblue10]

Yes, I agree that MPs should be grilled but I actually found this particular interview uncomfortable to watch.

[wolf63]

This is a link to the programme

[Peter Pedant]

He was rude to the black lady DIanne Abbott when she said Mid lothian question
whereas he snapped West Lothian question

that is the thing about scots MPs voting on English issues

altho if you goggle Midlothian question it does score ....

She shrugged it off
presumably used to it and knew what to do