Doctor?

[Maisy]

Did anyone watch Doctor Who tonight?

I certainly found it hard to watch because (compared to the last episodes with the old Doctor) it was BORING! The Doctor didnt do every much apart from sleep and have a sword fight that justs happens to save the world!! I'm sorry but that was VERY disappointing!!

I hope that the new series is not as boring.

the last series was amazing with a wonderful Doctor!!!! why on earth Chris left, i dont know! but i wish he hadnt left! Doctor Who is nothing without Chris E!!

[LeMarchand]

I thought it was really good! Was a bit worried about David Tennant (based on his past performances), but he certainly seems to have dialled it down a bit - unlike Eccleston, who (despite being a good actor normally) seemed to play the part like someone who had snorted half a kilo of cocaine and was trying to win first prize in a gurning contest.

The Xmas tree was a bit iffy, but the mentions for the new spin-off show "Torchwood" were intriguing, and there weren't any of the "ooh look at me, I can put gay references into a teatime show" bits that plagued the last season. Whilst it wasn't anywhere near the standard of my current (currently running) fave SF show - Battlestar Galactica - it was quite promising.

[meltoadhall]

I really enjoyed it, didnt like the last series. lots going to be happening in the new series.

[Kay]

We thouroughly enjoyed it. The doc had to sleep as he was regenarating but boring? Nah great stuff:--)))

[newquizzer]

Like the others I prefer this doctor to the last one.

The ending was a bit iffy though, earthlings totally destroying an alien craft!

[magicbeatle]

I thought David Tenant was superb, and will get better with time (Pun Intended), but the story line was lousy. I am sure the scripts will improve though.

[Mattk]

i thought the sword fight was totally naff but otherwise the episode was good.

personally,i thought eccleston made a brilliant doctor.i would certainly put him up there alongside my favourite - tom baker.

[Nummy]

I agree with mattk...Christopher Eccleston was a fab doctor...right up there with Tom Baker!

But i wouldn't write Mr Tennant off...i think he could join the esteemed ranks of Baker and Eccleston...it was just a bit of a slow start that's all. I think he'll be great!

[Maisy]

David Tenant is really bad!!! im sorry but how can u say he is any good? Eccleston is a lot better. He was funny, good-looking and an excellent actor. Tenant is just the opposite! BRING BACK THE OLD DOCTOR!!!

[Cymbeline]

I thought it was absolutely fantastic! Only thing worth watching on the telly this Christmas and David Tennant is remarkable. Handsome, funny, quirky, a fabulous actor and so goddamn sexy!! Do you remember how long it took to get used to Eccleston? I have fallen in love with Tennant from the off. Even the rest of the cast seem to bounce off his energy and there is a beautiful chemistry between him and Rose. PS. Who thinks long coats and suits are gonna be highly fashionable again?

[glenis]

maisy,were we watching a different show ? i thought it was one of the best i have seen . i was very apprehensive about david tennant after watching him in secret smile and casanova ,but all i can say is wow!! what a doctor! i am hooked -line and sinker , disappointing? -no , boring ? far from it ,just look into those eyes how can you resist?

[Joe Shmoe]

HI Maisy, I really enjoyed it! I have enjoyed the different traits of every doctor as each one offers something different. It came joint 2nd with Coronation Street in the Christmas Day ratings (9.4 Million) not bad.