louis walsh leaving x factor

[gina32]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/64322 49.stm
and kate thornton, is this good or bad

[Metz]

Depends who they get to host and judge instead of :o)

[katangel26]

I never liked Louis as a judge (he was far too baised) but I thought Kate Thornton was brilliant as a presenter. So good and bad lol

[luckyeight]

Good thing. Louis only ever judged contestants on whether or not he wanted their **** in his ******....

[gina32]

lucky eight dont be pathetic

[Pippa68]

Good thing about Louis, but I thought Kate was a good presenter.

I will never forgive Louis Walsh for giving us Girls Aloud ;o)

Not that I am that bothered about the X Factor to be honest..it lost it's spark ages ago!

[curlyperm]

i agree with pippa i too think it lost its spark ages ago! even the 'crap' auditions stopped being funny........just tedious. Louis walsh going........wouldnt bother me either way, (shouty) Kate Thornton - couldnt stand her, although i have to grudgingly admit that she held the show together, plus, anyone who takes her place will automatically be compered, i heard that cat deeley was favourite for that positon?

[4getmenot]

Bad thing they should axe the whole show

[markjlett]

Don't you think this is just hype? Louis Walsh and Simon Cowell are very rich businessmen. They were at the Oscars together two weeks ago FFS!

This is just a ploy to get publicity. Louis Walsh will be managing whoever wins but a change of face to someone more well known and popular will increase viewers.

I doubt that Paula Abdul could be away from the bar long enough to do the UK show!

As for Kate Thornton she was a wooly presenter who couldn't listen to her interviewee because she had to concentrate on the Autocue. The Gig was too big for her

[stokeace]

whats happened to the last 3 winners anyway?its a waste of time.

[glammapus]

Excellent news. I love X Factor but kate thornton winds me up. She is such a wooden presenter and never seems to have much emotion or personality. Anyone can read an autocue, and she's not exactly pleasing to the eye.

[gina32]

well glammapus she might not do anything for you but i bet she does for a lot of people

[curlyperm]

hey stokeace...........can i just point out that cute little Ray (tw*t) aka Eddie Munster was on Entertainment Today/GMTV (AHEM) so............it doesnt get much better than THAT!!! and for anyone who wants to know (or even gives a to**) his little single is out on Monday, dont get crushed in the stampede outside HMV now - i'd set off now if i were you, see ya there! lol

[poolger]

I quite liked Louis and Kate. I heard rumours, hopefully not true that Big Bro Shilpa is going to be a judge.

[ELVIS68]

Louis Walsh (he`s Irish btw) shouldn`t leave, Sharon should go, she`s no judge of talent
As for Kate Thornton...would anyone miss her?...Nah

Melinda Messenger would be better

[tinac]

In the paper today it stated that Dermot O;Leary would take over and jessica Simpson (who ??) would be a judge

[Tizzi247]

I'm glad they're going. Its got to be an even better show without them!

[badboy4life]

if melinda messenger presented it with jo guest throw in i may start watching it, lol