Editor's Blog3 mins ago
Lost in Austen
10 Answers
Did any ardent fans of Pride & Prejudice watch this - and if so, what did you think? P&P is one of the all-time classics - wonderful stuff - and I'm always dubious when something like this is given an alternative slant, but this was cleverly constructed and highly watchable - and I found the conclusion very satisfying indeed!
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by naomi24. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.Pride and Prejudice is one of my favourite books. I haven't watched Lost in Austen. Partly because there's only so many programmes you can watch - I can't keep up with them all if I watch too many! And partly because I've read The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde - and it sounded to me as though the writer of Lost in Austen may have read The Eyre Affair and got a little idea from that!
I haven't read The Eyre Affair, but I have read a couple of sequels to P&P, which were a great disappointment. As I said, I am always dubious of follow-ups to things like this. Some writers just jump on popular bandwagons, only to come tumbling off again because they fall so very short of the required mark - but this, I thought, was excellent. And quizzywig - I agree - the ending was fabulous!!
I have to be careful because Mrs M taped last nights finale and I haven't watched it yet.............
I think it has been a marvellous romp through P&P. I found that the 'real' P&P characters inhabit an entirely plausible Austen-world and their actions outside the 'real' narrative are completely in-keeping with that world. Each of the actors/actresses could be teleported out of this series and arrive in any adaptation of P&P and fit smoothly.........
I have read Jasper FFordes books and the similarities are there but 'Lost in Austen' is less complicated fare.
I am looking forwards to supper-time tonight !!
But please.................NO SPOILERS !! :o)
I think it has been a marvellous romp through P&P. I found that the 'real' P&P characters inhabit an entirely plausible Austen-world and their actions outside the 'real' narrative are completely in-keeping with that world. Each of the actors/actresses could be teleported out of this series and arrive in any adaptation of P&P and fit smoothly.........
I have read Jasper FFordes books and the similarities are there but 'Lost in Austen' is less complicated fare.
I am looking forwards to supper-time tonight !!
But please.................NO SPOILERS !! :o)
Well!!
Mrs M's eyes were shining with tears of delight at the conclusion of this very enjoyable mini-series.
I think it all ended exactly as it ought. I can't remember the last time both of us watched a programme which we so enjoyed on exactly the same level footing.
I studied P&P at school and whilst I appreciated the fiestiness and independent thought of Elizabeth Bennett, even at the end of the book I couldn't quite believe in Darcy's 'redemption'; he'd been too much of an insufferable prig for me to grow to admire him at the end. Or perhaps that was youth being unable to grasp the intricacies of the social mores of the era and the fact that I thought I ought to be given a stab at making Lizzie happy ? :o)
The many TV/film adaptations I have watched (some more unwillingly than other I'll admit) have done little to disabuse me of either notion...........
I firmly believe that Mrs M will be first in the queue at HMV when this series comes to DVD.
And I firmly believe that I will also enjoy watching it all again.
Mrs M's eyes were shining with tears of delight at the conclusion of this very enjoyable mini-series.
I think it all ended exactly as it ought. I can't remember the last time both of us watched a programme which we so enjoyed on exactly the same level footing.
I studied P&P at school and whilst I appreciated the fiestiness and independent thought of Elizabeth Bennett, even at the end of the book I couldn't quite believe in Darcy's 'redemption'; he'd been too much of an insufferable prig for me to grow to admire him at the end. Or perhaps that was youth being unable to grasp the intricacies of the social mores of the era and the fact that I thought I ought to be given a stab at making Lizzie happy ? :o)
The many TV/film adaptations I have watched (some more unwillingly than other I'll admit) have done little to disabuse me of either notion...........
I firmly believe that Mrs M will be first in the queue at HMV when this series comes to DVD.
And I firmly believe that I will also enjoy watching it all again.