Judges on X-factor.

[maggie01]

Do you think they are getting two personal with each other? It is one thing to give their opinions of each act but arguing amongst themselves must make the contestants very uncomfortable. Simon's remarks to the McDonald brothers is totally uncalled for. They may not be his cup of tea and there are probably better acts on X-Factor, but they have feelings. Not very nice.

[Netty7]

I normally agree with everything Simon says cos he tells the truth and knows what he's talking about, but I think he'd lost the plot tonite! He kept saying that everyone sounded like something from the 80's but - hello - the music was from the 80's (and earlier). And he tried to make it from the 40's with Ray - it just didn't work!

[hibeeslass]

They say that Abba songs are the most difficult to sing....I'm a proud scottish lass but i have to say the mcdonald bros need a good shake they can sing, but they have no personalities, they are wooden!i know that sounds harsh but we are letting our Scottish hearts rule our heads here! x

[ELVIS68]

I only saw the end results tonight but last week Simon got it spot on about Kerry being a hotel singer, and then that freak of a woman..Sharon....comes out with the line...Yes I agree Simon...The International Hotel Las Vegas!

Has she been taking Ossies drugs?

[caz247]

I think sometimes the judges just act in front of the cameras to get ratings . If Simon calls them the mcdougall
bros once more i think i'll scream. and his constant comparing acts to hotel singers
i'm glaswegian but jeez the mcdonald bros are awful
still compulsive viewing though lol

caz x

[Paul22118]

Simon's last comment to the Irishman said it all. Ashley was sacrificed to keep Robert in and therefore maintain a balanace of acts for the judges. Louie's fear is Simon waltzing into the final session with all four acts intact.

MacDougall, McDonals Mac whatever - how the hell do they manage to keep the public vote each week? Does all Scotland vote for them?

[smurfchops]

cas247 I agree, it is all for ratings, I doubt if as many people are watching now the funny auditions are over, it is a bit boring now zzzzzzzzzz