Mixed media

[Waterwolf]

Which is better, CD or vinyl?

[andy hughes]

From a purely technical point of view, CD reproduction has the edge, most modern recordings utilise computer technology which carries through to the CD reproduction, with negligable loss of sound quality. Vinyl albums were usually made from analogue tape, and did loose some of the higher frequencies in the pressing stages. In terms of longevity and storage, CD's have the edge again - their compact size and durability ensures a longer life than vinyl which wears with age, no matter how carefully it is cared for. Purists insist that vinyl has a 'warmer' sound than CD, although the vast majority of listeners are either unable to detect the difference, or don't especially care to listen for it. The world takeover of CD's as the format of choice, and the sidelining of vinyl to dance tracks and die-hard enthusiasts demonstrates most people's preference.

[julia]

trust andy to get technical. i love nothing more than listening to my old 45s and LPs(i always thought only morons called them albums...)every scratch tells a story...

[andy hughes]

You're quite right, I did get technical, but only in the interests of answering the question. From a music fan's point of view, I miss the brilliant cover artwork that we got on album sleeves, especially the gatefold and triple ones - it's all gone now, no point on such a small space as a CD sleeve. I know a lot of vinyl fans swear by their vinyl albums (sorry I've been calling them that for 30 years, I can't stop now!) but I do prefer CDs. I once returned 12 (!) copies of Pink Floyd's 'Meddle' before I got one that didn't crackle and click through 'Echoes', ruining the mood. My nurtured copy lasted about a week before it clicked and crackled anway, but my CD copy gives me perfect plays year in year out. It's all down to personal choice, but the music is what matters.