Film, Media & TV64 mins ago
Should we obey this European rule?
23 Answers
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by anotheoldgit. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.The GMC can't stop europeans from working here - but the Employers are the actual arbiter.
If your GP practice/local hospital is employing a new doctor (or arranging a locum contract) they have the legal right to decide what the communication skills requirement is for that post.
If they predominantly serve a Polish community or a French School- fine -but I think in the vast majority of cases they will make the appropriate candidate selection and if inability to communicate with patients is a factor they will not contravene any 'laws' whatsoever.
.
If your GP practice/local hospital is employing a new doctor (or arranging a locum contract) they have the legal right to decide what the communication skills requirement is for that post.
If they predominantly serve a Polish community or a French School- fine -but I think in the vast majority of cases they will make the appropriate candidate selection and if inability to communicate with patients is a factor they will not contravene any 'laws' whatsoever.
.
Old Git
Agreed. There have i believe been terrible cases of incompetent doctors coming in from abroad (as locums usually) and killing people.
I think the ultimate responsibility has to be the employer's. If someone here wants to employ a German doctor who can't speak english that's their business and can't be illegal. But if my hospital or GP puts a doctor in front of me I would hold them responsible for ensuring they are properly qualified, competent and can communicate with me.
.
Agreed. There have i believe been terrible cases of incompetent doctors coming in from abroad (as locums usually) and killing people.
I think the ultimate responsibility has to be the employer's. If someone here wants to employ a German doctor who can't speak english that's their business and can't be illegal. But if my hospital or GP puts a doctor in front of me I would hold them responsible for ensuring they are properly qualified, competent and can communicate with me.
.
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
"Foreign doctors whose English is so poor that they need interpreters are being allowed to operate on patients in Britain, the medical regulator has warned. "
It doesn't bother me one jot. If I was being operated on, the last thing on my mind would be to have a chinwag with the surgeon who was making me better.
It doesn't bother me one jot. If I was being operated on, the last thing on my mind would be to have a chinwag with the surgeon who was making me better.
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
My dentist, an Indian lady, speaks better English than I do. I have more difficulty understanding her Scottish colleague sometimes.
Thing is, though, when I meet medical professionals whose spoken English is poor, I can usually understand them because I've spent years working with and alongside people whose first language isn't English. But my mum, I know, has real problems understanding her GP sometimes. He's a wonderful doctor with a lovely bedside manner, but people of Mum's generation just aren't used to all these 'foreign' accents.
Thing is, though, when I meet medical professionals whose spoken English is poor, I can usually understand them because I've spent years working with and alongside people whose first language isn't English. But my mum, I know, has real problems understanding her GP sometimes. He's a wonderful doctor with a lovely bedside manner, but people of Mum's generation just aren't used to all these 'foreign' accents.
Yes, absolutely essential. Some doctors-on-call services employ EU doctors on short-term contracts to cover weekends etc - absolutely vital that they can not only read but understand patients' notes etc. I have worked with medics whose accents were very strong so they were hard to understand, but they did have the right terminology in language which was correct when written down.
-- answer removed --
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.