Donate SIGN UP

Is this terminology racist?

Avatar Image
anotheoldgit | 11:40 Mon 07th May 2012 | News
83 Answers
http://www.thesun.co....hat-it-is-racist.html

Does such ridiculous over-sensitive rulings such as this only go to create more divisions between the races?

It is as ridiculous as saying that sending someone to Coventry is offensive to the people of Coventry.
Gravatar

Answers

21 to 40 of 83rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next Last

Avatar Image
SP, no, it didn’t make me racist - but it made me angry. We’ve now reached a stage where little can be said or done without it being misconstrued by those who wish to appear to be politically correct. If anyone needs desensitising it’s those people because they create disharmony and conflict where there is none.
08:15 Tue 08th May 2012
It's all pathetic.
It's nonsense.
Black also has positive connotations

Many British people are proud of the achievements of The Black Watch (Royal Highland Regiment)

In Japan(black) is a symbol of nobility and experience, as opposed to shiro (white), which symbolizes serfdom, youth, and naiveté. The black belt is a highest grade in many martial arts, where a white belt is a rank-less belt that comes before all other belts.
The whole bloody country is totally obsessed with racism!!! Everywhere you look these day its "Racism racism racism!!" You open a news paper and you get racism.... you watch the news and its racism. We cant say this, we cant say that because we might offend. We cant do this and we cant do that because we might offend.
If anything bad, no matter how trivial, happens to a black man its racism. And the most annoying thing about it is, half the time its not the blacks complaining. Its pathetic moronic white do-gooders!!
I hate it when i walk down the road and i see a bunch of gangsta scum hoodies giving me black looks
when I was a boy I collected stamps and my prized possession was a penny black. Will this have to renamed as a penny off-colour?
Is there any surprise there are concerns about racism when there are folk such as anotheoldgit who believes a black man can not be English?
You're completely missing the point! A Penny Black was so named because its background colour actually was black! cf Penny Blue. A blackboard is similarly named because that's what colour it is.

A blacklist isn't. Can you honestly not see the difference...?
There's another way of looking at this story - there's always been a quirk of the English language where many words/phrase containing the word 'black' are negative (blacklist, blackballed, blackmail, giving black looks).

However, the term 'black' meaning 'of *** origin' only really took off in late 50s America, around the time of the Civil Rights campaigns.

Because the origins of some words and phrases have been lost to the mists of time, they appear when in fact they are entirely innocent.
There you now have it in Black and White...............er, am I still allowed to say that?
Can we not Blackball anyone now, either?
thejudderman

I understand your point, but I'd much rather be irritated by people being over-zealous, than actually being the Victim of racism - you know...from the casual everyday racism right up to the two recent incidents in Salford.
I think "black ball" would be similarly inappropriate.

Note the words - Not racist

Nobody's said it was Racist - that was AOG who used that term

Incidently - who are "the races"? when race acquire a definate artcle as if there was some unchanging definative concept of rcae?
researching -Blacklist- keeps returning a link to Charles11
and not slavery.

Am I looking in the wrong places ?
The neologism 'whitelist' as the opposite of blacklist is a false formation.

Black in blacklist (a word first recorded in 1620) is there because we have long used 'black' as a negative term:'Things are not as black as they seem', 'she gave him black looks' ,'black comedy', 'blackleg' 'black market'. Try substituting 'white' in those. They make no opposite sense; we wouldn't say them because 'white' as a colour has not had the positive meanings that black has as a negative.

Not difficult to see why. Night and darkness, lack of daylight, is seen as negative, depressing, bad, associated with death.

Black for a skin colour is only one of its uses. But people have been defined by it as they have by white. Since 'white' is a term for white-skinned people and black for black-skinned and white is not the opposite of white in most contexts (see above) 'whitelist' sounds racist. But it tells more about the sensitivity of those who would ban it than about any actual racist thought it conveys.

It ought to be banned on the ground that it is not a good formation, not a proper opposite, in English, of blacklist, not for any other reason.
Not forgetting black clouds.

Like most of this nonsense it is a matter of opinion since there is no sensible definition. What is acceptable or even preferred one year is considered awful the next.

I take it the heads of police were just having a wind-up, or maybe the reporters were. Is it April the first again already?
thats stupid! I bet those police chiefs are all white men, theres too many people like that now, 'cant sing ba ba black sheep, cant say black bin bag, its a refuse sack' jeez the list goes on, too many doo-gooders. My brother has fallen out with me and stopped talking to me because I told my sister I had a dream where a guy from the congo lied to her about his age - long story short, he told me I'm racist and 'have a deep-seared hatred for anyone you deem to be foreign' I showed all of my foreign friends, they thought he was crazy. Its way over the top now, soon we wont be able to say 'black' it will be noir........but then again, this was in The Sun, so dont believe everything
So as it seems the word black is going to be blacklisted, and no surprises who in this post are trying to justify it, the same three can always can be relied upon, what are we going to call blacks then ? any offers
> the same three can always can be relied upon

Outstanding!
Question Author
http://www.dailymail....racter-womaniser.html

It is catching, even our Maiden Aunt's favourite radio show is up for criticism, this time for stereotyping black males.

One would have thought in a non visual medium such as radio, it would make little difference if one happened to be black or white.

21 to 40 of 83rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Is this terminology racist?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.