Donate SIGN UP

Falklands Referendum: The Islanders Have Spoken

Avatar Image
ChillDoubt | 03:20 Tue 12th Mar 2013 | News
46 Answers
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-21750909

What I can't fathom is who were the 3 who voted against?

Or were there 3 jokers just having a laugh?
Gravatar

Answers

21 to 40 of 46rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by ChillDoubt. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Question to David Cameron here - Why won't you face Alex Salmond in a live TV debate on independence?
There is more than one option for the Falklands other than to remain an 'Overseas Territory of the UK'.

They could opt for independence or become commonwealth states like say the Solomon Islands.

Presumably the 3 would rather have gone for that.

However this is probably the most decisive result in any genuine election ever. (unless anyone can find a better one?)

Argentina might contest the right of the islanders to be there in the first place and hence the validity of the vote at all, however by any sensible account they're at least 100 years too late.

I do find it amusing to recall though in 1982 how few people had ever heard of the Falkland Islands

- the joke was of people thinking that Argentina had invated part of the Hebrides!
Arguably more impressive was the referendum on Gibraltar's sovereignty in 2002
where there was a 98.4% rejection of the power-sharing proposal (out of 18,000 votes)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibraltar_sovereignty_referendum,_2002

There have been numerous fraudulent referenda on various things
Question Author
Just read this elsewhere:

The Falklanders have voted to stay British with a vote of 1,517 to 3. In other island news Jose Gonzales, Juan Miguel and Peto Sosa woke this morning to find someone had sh*t through their letterboxes.
Do you suppose the Argentinians know the meaning of the word "democracy " ?
Dunno

Do you think the US does?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apology_Resolution
///Question to David Cameron here - Why won't you face Alex Salmond in a live TV debate on independence? ///

it's got chuff all to do with cameron, surely? it's a decision for the scottish electorate, and it's for Mr Salmond and his government to act on that decision..........
Question Author
Is there any reason why the US has been mentioned in a dispute between the UK and Argentina over sovereignty?
^
Well US support or lack of it is often referred to in debates on Falklands sovereignty.

It is worth remembering that the US does have 'form' in relation to The Hawaiian Islands, parallels with Alaska and some 'interesting' situations such as their take-over of Texas.
mushroom25, I couldn't agree more. My post was in response to a previous post by ichkeria.
If Scotland becomes an independent nation like Argentina

will the Shetland Islanders get a referendum similar to the Falklanders?
interesting point...
I wonder how much it costs the taxpayer to keep them there and - if we offered them the same amount - they would come back here where they seem to want to be?
They should get out of our hair and arrange a leaseback like they did with Hong Kong. After about 60 years most of the islanders will be dead and the island can revert to Argentinian sovereignty.
In an independent Scotland there is no reason why Shetland shouldn't conduct a referendum similar to that held in the Falklands. However, the issue would be discussed by their fellow countrymen in Holyrood and not a parcel of foreigners in Westminster.
The question posed to the Falklanders was quite straightforward:

“Do you wish the Falkland Islands to retain their current political status as an Overseas Territory of the United Kingdom?”

The accompanying literature provided to the islanders stated that if a majority of voters opted for a change of status further information regarding the options and possible ways forward would be provided.

Unlike many people I had certainly heard of the Falklands before they became “famous” in 1982. I visited the islands a few years earlier, making a stop-off in Stanley on my way to a stint in Antarctica. The place was certainly not one I would choose to live but the impression I gained during my (admittedly very short) stopover was of the fiercely British nature that the people there demonstrated. Their “culture and diversity” had not been diluted by the types of influxes that have hit the UK and they seem none the worse for it. The islands have a GDP of £100m, giving them a GDP per head of about £40k, somewhat more prosperous than the UK.

Of course I’ll use this issue to have my usual dig at the UK’s present government and the EU. It is interesting to note that Mr Cameron fiercely defends the islanders’ right to determine their own governance and future. It’s just a pity that he does not behave similarly fiercely to defend the rights of UK citizens who are witnessing their governance being stealthily transferred to the EU.
lol Wharton I can assure you that the Shetlanders consider the foreigners to be in Holyrood not Westminster..........
I'm in Glasgow craft and I agree with them :-)
“…they would come back here where they seem to want to be? “

They don’t want to be here, Ric,ror. They don’t want to be here any more than Shetland Islanders want to live in London. They want to remain where they are, remain doing what they do and remain a British Overseas Territory.

As far as finances go, the islands are largely self-financing apart from the cost of the military garrison that has been there since 1982. Of course this is considerable but it is hardly the islanders’ fault that it is necessary any more than a garrison on the Channel Islands or the Isle of Wight would be needed if those place had been invaded by a foreign power.

“…and the island can revert to Argentinian sovereignty. “

Do your history first, pdq. The Falkland Islands have never been under the sovereignty of Argentina.
since when was it Argentine sovereignty?

21 to 40 of 46rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Falklands Referendum: The Islanders Have Spoken

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.