Crosswords1 min ago
Civil liberties...take your pick
Which civil liberties would you now give up if asked, that you would not have given up last month? Biometric ID cards? Microchip implant? Centralized car tracking? Frequent police stop and search?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by MargeB. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
I think ID cards is the big one, isn't it? This is now really going to happen apparently.
It is often said that rushed legislation is bad legislation. When legislation starts out as badly as Blunkett's ID Card scheme and is then rushed it can only get worse.
The imposition of ID Cards on innocent British citizens is a major constitutional change for which the Government has no mandate. Any vote on such a controversial issue must be a free vote.
For everyone who is up for an ID card i would advise having a read through this site http://www.no2id.net/ I bet you will change your mind when you realise that this is not just a piece of plastic but a national database on a scale that exists nowhere else in the world. You will be required to provide at least 50 pieces of information about yourself and if you dont comply or keep your information up to date at all times you will be subject to a �2500 fine (im not joking have you read the bill?). This is Hitlers fantasy guys and the resistance is growing! And forget all the governments arguments about why we need it each and everyone has been challenged by credible professionals.
Very honestly, I would give up all these 'liberties' now and would have years ago. There are greater liberties, those of not being stabbed to death on a bus because I didn't like being pelted with chips, or being blown up on a train because someone doesn't like my culture or religion. Those who have nothing to hide have nothing to fear, indeed wish actively to contribute to the security of our society and whole way of life.
And how on earth would having your freedom taken away make you more safe? There are plenty of innocent people with reason to hide and plenty to fear such as victims of domestic abuse, witnesses to crime etc. As for giving up your freedom for a little security you are basically spitting upon the graves of generations of people who have fought to protect those freedoms and died to protect them.
The problem is that this is all "thin end of the wedge stuff". You may not be being told that there will be fines for not carrying them or keeping them up to date but this is all "enabling legislation" that means it gives the Home Secretatry power to introduce measures at his discretion.
My wife's family were Jews in Autria and fled to Ireland in the 30's - strangely none of them think that "people with nothing to hide have nothing to fear".
Can't imagine why
If you want to claim your 7 virgins, yes.
I think Jake's reference to Jews is entirely pertinent, a perfect example of how the State does not necessarily have the best intentions for all of its populous all of the time. The current nazi party, excuse me, labour party would take all they could, given the chance.
It's an extreme example I grant you but I do think that to assume that if you have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide is a trifle naive.
I'm also pretty confident that these will become compusorary to carry very shortly after their introduction - or else what is the point? we can all produce sufficient id on demand already.
And if it's compulsory then there have to be penalties for not complying.
I can see this being about as popular as speed cameras in ten years time.
This discussion goes nowhere when you get absurd comments like : "As for giving up your freedom for a little security you are basically spitting upon the graves of generations of people who have fought to protect those freedoms and died to protect them." And: "The current nazi party, excuse me, labour party would take all they could, given the chance."
I'm not necessarily for ID cards, but I would certainly give up a small amount of my freedom in order to gain a little more security. We did this in World War 2, and those who fought and died realised this and didn't jeapordise our national security by constantly maintaining their individual "rights" all the time. They knew that they had responsibilities too.
Some are more concerned with upholding extreme Liberal ideology, no matter how many lives are lost.
It's not all about "rights" (sic: your inverted commas) and "duties". Its also about the individual versus the state. The state is set up by the individuals for the individuals, and ultimately the individual and his/her freedoms are the most important thing. I should be able to live my life with as few encroachments from the State as possible. CCTV cameras everywhere, high profile policing, ID cards, snooping, closed-government, unaccountable government decisions, lying government, random stop and search all encroach on my liberty as an individual. Some have to be taken at a cost, but all should be seriously questioned. This (nazi) government FORGETS this. Blunkett TOLD us that we would have ID cards, we TOLD him to **** off, and he had to back down, and admitted such.
The approach of the current "government" to all levels of civil liberties and the rights of the individual are getting very close to 'Nazi'. YOU will do what THEY think is best because THEY know better. **** *** Tony.
Isn't "extreme liberal" an oxymoron? At any rate I think there is a danger in accepting a simple "id card = fewer lives lost" argument. There simply doesn't seem to be any evidence to support it. There is also a danger in seeing this as a "small amount of freedom". My non- British European friends have always carried id cards ( a legacy of WWII?) but these are very simple, have a few minimal physical details, a signature and a photo. At any given time, these days, I carry a wealth of identifiying detail anyway including cards with photos and signatures. What is proposed for the id cards in this country goes beyond anything which has gone before, anywhere. I am not, in principle, against carrying an id card but I am concerned that we will more and more easily accept constant surveilance and control as part of our lives and over time slip into a kind of 1984 state without noticing. Consider - already electronic communication is monitored, almost every part of towns and cities is covered by TV cameras. Now these things are done for the protection of citizens and I am as grateful as anyone for the efforts of the police and other authorities to save me from being shot or blown up but let's not stop questioning the need for, or merits of, reduced freedoms. What comes next? Tighter control of media? Even greater censorship? Regular stop and search? Extensive tagging of persons or vehicles? Having to answer to authority for the anti-government tone of your AB posts? O.K. it sounds paranoid but let's just continue to question anyway and not give away freedoms too easily. the government are at best just fallible human beings like you or I and while we can hope that "they know best" there is a danger inherent in unquestioningly believing it. As for paying for the card, I am sure we will do that one way or another. If not a separate charge then via our taxes.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.