Donate SIGN UP

Breaking: Phenom Jet Crash At Blackbushe Airport

Avatar Image
Hypognosis | 17:48 Fri 31st Jul 2015 | News
57 Answers
BBC website sometimes flashes breaking news at you. No one else has posted about this.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-surrey-33736685


Not a lot to debate, this is a JFYI. There is a car auction site at the end of the runway and it may have overshot in the landing.

Gravatar

Answers

41 to 57 of 57rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3

Avatar Image
Sounds like a routine landing that went tits up. Maybe a failure of the breaks or reverse thrust.
19:19 Fri 31st Jul 2015
After all R-Cop....you and I have been known to agree with each other from time to time !
Mikey
Very true but it don't arf get boring. :-)
I am not sure it happens often enough to get boring !
Bouncer33. The Bin Laden Group is one of the largest businesses in the middle east. It is worth £billions . They do a huge amount of trade with the UK. Osama Bin Laden was one of the sons , he became a terrorist leader and was disowned by the family, just because one member of a family becomes a criminal does not make criminals of the rest of the family.
Well said Eddie !

I think you are barking up the wrong tree here Bouncer. There are plenty of topics concerning dave and the present savage Tory administration to make comments on, but this isn't one of them.
Are we supposed to believe this?
The Bin Laden women were most probably going to do a bit of shopping in Knightsbridge.
it might have been cheaper to buy Heathrow, tonyav; it's closer to Knightsbridge.

Some bafflement here (it quotes the website kindly linked to by Eddie last night)

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/aug/01/aviation-experts-bin-laden-plane-crash-cause
-- answer removed --
I have to admit it is a bit odd. The plane was a regular visitor to Blackbushe and the crew knew the place well. Yet they managed to overshoot the runway. The aircraft had all the latest 'state of the art' auto land technology , why did it happen ?? In perfect conditions as well?
Question Author
@EDDIE51

Over-familiarity with ones surroundings does impinge on safety. Statistics bear out that most car accidents happen within a few miles of home. A punch of salt with that though, since the school run (a recent innovation, from my perspective) will be short, many work commutes are under 10 miles and the headline of the statistic was "under 25 miles", which allows for longer weekend jaunts.

I hesitate to apply this factor to aircraft. Being casual or careless with a car, at commuter speeds has relatively minor consequences. Being airborne should sharpen the senses to the point that no mistakes are made.


I don't know for certain but I would be willing to bet that Auto-Land is heavily dependent on Instrument Landing System (ILS) equipment at the airport. It is uneconomic to have such expensive gear at an airport which has very little daily traffic and a cursory internet search shows Blackbushe doesn't have one.

Auto-Land would also require full control of the throttles in order to regulate the approach speed. I am sure it would take more than 18 seconds on final to reduce any excess speed, stabilise the powered glide and it would take some fancy software to *reliably* decide that an auto-go-around was appropriate.

The PPRUNE thread continued with much discussion of this 1.43 multiplier (of landing roll, compared to manufacturer specifications). One pointed out that, whilst the runway length was fine, on the face of it, there was no margin for error and, by the time the pilot realises it is time to reject the landing, there is not enough time to spool up the engines to take off power. Whether the multiplier is intended to include extra runway required for go around I hope to find out later.

Anyway, this is the long-winded way of saying that all the onboard high-tech equipment in the workd won't save you if you hand-fly the thing and go too fast (PPRUNE thread again; mention of 149kts, over the runway threshold).

Looks like something similar happened ( with a beechcraft light jet ) a few years ago at Blackbushe.
http://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/bin-laden-plane-crash-jet-went-down-in-near-perfect-conditions/ar-BBlifrx
Question Author
Thanks tony.

That piece shows what little understanding the press has: "runway fitted with safety equipment", for instance. Reiterated a paragraph later, specifying PAPI which is only an indication of too-high/low on the approach, not arrestor gear, which might just save your hide if you land too fast.

That said, I am still cautious over the AIS data from which one of the PPRUNE correspondents got that thing about the approach speed. When I use Flightradar24, the AIS data sometimes pauses for a few seconds then catches up in a burst of information. Only the onboard data recorder (if fitted) can tell us the truth.

As divebuddy first pointed out, we should await the investigation findings. Second guessing the outcome may be normal, on AB, in regard to criminal investigations but is frowned upon, in the case of transportation accidents, probably for reasons of taste and deference to the deceased. My own desire to learn new things sometimes makes me neglect matters of taste. I apologise to anyone adversely affected by that.



Question Author
@Tony

The witness in the MSN story refers to an incident involving a Beechjet *nearly* hitting the fuel dump. I haven't found any online news related to that so we'll treat it as apocryphal, for now.

As a non-damage incident, it has not made it into the ASN database. User-added data is welcomed there but they do insist on reliable reference material like wikipedia.

This, for instance, was a Beechcraft Super King Air, not a Beechjet. It's unlikely that a spotter-ish witness would get the two muddled up.

http://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20001223-1


In the meantime, I remain puzzled by the lack of eyewitness testimony from control tower staff but, if it is light on traffic, it may be an uncontrolled field, with ATC provided by Farnborough or another neighbour.

Can anyone clarify that point?
“A Beechcraft light jet just missed the fuel dump on the other side of the runway some years ago,” the pilot claimed.

Mmmm, he says light jet however it looks like the plane in your link has propellers, Hypognosis.
Question Author
After further browsing, I found this. Listed as Raytheon but, superficially, similar to Beechjet. (Insert your corrections here).

http://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20040407-0

41 to 57 of 57rss feed

First Previous 1 2 3

Do you know the answer?

Breaking: Phenom Jet Crash At Blackbushe Airport

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.