Should This Woman Be Banned For Life From Entering The Uk?

[anotheoldgit]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5544219/Canadian-far-right-activist-claimed-Allah-gay-gets-lifetime-ban-coming-UK.html

/// A Home Office Spokesperson said: 'Border Force has the power to refuse entry to an individual if it is considered that his or her presence in the UK is not conducive to the public good.' ///

They may have the power, but do they implement it so forceful for others, since we have many here who's presence is not conductive to the public's good.?

[emmie]

of all places to hand out leaflets proclaiming Allah is gay
would be Luton, which has a high Asian, Muslim population, quite honestly i think she sounds deranged, banning her would be a good idea.

[anotheoldgit]

Agree with spathiphyllum on this one, there was not danger to the public at large, she was in more danger herself if anything.

[emmie]

she was i agree ^^

[naomi24]

No. We let far worse in - and they're not conducive to the public good either.

[Kromovaracun]

Unless there is a clear and present threat from her - no, there's no reason to ban her for life (which is a ludicrously extreme measure). I'm not entirely comfortable with the state getting to decide what is in the public interest or not (outside of truly obvious threats to safety of course) and determining immigration that way.

[anthro-nerd]

//If she personally believes allah is a trans,(i dont beleive she does) at least she is acknowledging his existence//

You know Spath, I can actually see your logic here :-P I agree!!

[Mamyalynne]

She has discovered the hard way that when you decide to conduct a 'Social experiment' you may not always get the result you expected.

[vetuste_ennemi]

There is nothing "far right" about Ms Southern as anyone who's seen any of her YouTube videos will know. She is a libertarian who is for free speech and against Islam - a perfectly consistent logical position.

If the "social experiment" in Luton was meant to demonstrate the special privileges accorded to Muslims by the British police it succeeded well.

Here's Ms. Southern distributing her "racist" material in Luton. PC Plod turns up three and a half minutes into the video accusing Southern of committing a "public order" offence, by which he meant that some Muslims were likely to become violent (to be honest a perfectly fair point) and ordering her to surrender the offensive "racist" material.

[Mamyalynne]

Discount my earlier answer then and amend it to 'she got the result she expected'.

[andy-hughes]

I think that if the Border Force is going to flex its muscles in the interests of banning people who are not conducive to the public good, then, as others have suggested, it needs to indulge in a galaxy-sized sense of even-handedness, and ensure that anyone, from any country, race, or creed, who is not conducive to the public good is banned under the same legislation.

To do otherwise undermines the system, and the reputation for impartiality that it must maintain in order to function properly.

[naomi24]

Spath, //their is a line between having your say, and protesting / preaching crap. //

One man's crap is another's .... err ... gospel. ;o)