Question Author
I totally agree with your opening sentence, Gromit! Indeed, I imagined I'd said as much in my opening sentence, referring to a (quote) "balancing claim"!
Neither claim is true, as you say. The point, however, is that right-wingers here and elsewhere have been getting away virtually unquestioned with THEIR claim, so I felt it was time for others to query their attitude...the Bible's word rather than mine applies.
VE, you don't appear to have got any wiser than you were when we first met in Q&P all those years ago. I would have been delighted to pass on your regards to Gribble, but I have seen no sign of her for years, mainly I suppose because I only very infrequently visit there. Is she still around? I hope so and would be pleased to know that there is still someone prepared to help her in answering ANY newspaper crossword clue she asks about!