Donate SIGN UP

Sadiq Khan Sets Up A Commision For Vandalising London...

Avatar Image
ToraToraTora | 14:38 Tue 09th Jun 2020 | News
53 Answers
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 53rss feed

1 2 3 Next Last

Avatar Image
jim360 - // There is a clear gulf between statues celebrating people who, perhaps, should not be so celebrated, and between the buildings their ill-gotten gains have provided. // Actually, there isn't, quite the opposite in fact. If you start analysing philanthropy based on the income source, where on earth do you stop? Are you going to say that millowners...
16:35 Tue 09th Jun 2020
Oh there’s gonna be a commission for to vandaliseLondon now .Whats the world coming to .
What's this obsession with Mandela's terrorism, given that he was quite important in overturning the horrific apartheid policy? Such a blatantly racist law and social system deserved to be challenged strongly.
As to the statues, what matters -- and what was lacking in Bristol -- is societal consent. If a review leads to proposals to remove such-and-such a statue then, hopefully, the citizens too will be consulted. In either case, a more honest appraisal of our past can hardly be welcome. We're constantly assured that removing statues is an erasure of history, which rings a lot more hollow if those raising this protest are determined to ignore a significant chunk of it.
//Such a blatantly racist law and social system deserved to be challenged strongly. //

how strongly, Jim? is anti racism so important that murder becomes acceptable?

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/opinion/the-dark-side-of-nelson-mandela/news-story/68f4acdbf2b0b4e6c799e458a55e6cb2
"All statues in London will be examined with a view to removing those with links to slavery and plantation owners, Sadiq Khan has said."

Unsure I see much public consultation there. In fact I'm of the opinion councils avoid consultation, or ignore it's outcome if they don't like it, as an affront to their control.

By removing statues, is that not a prime example of trying to ignore history ? Removsl of evidence. Denial at it's crystal clearest.
Removal
Not just in London - they want Francis Drake's statue on Plymouth Hoe to be removed.
Question Author
gawd elp us, what did Drake do?
I'd argue that calling apartheid "racism" is an understatement and then some. Every aspect of a non-white South African's life was proscribed, every human freedom curtailed. There could be no democratic solution if the affected populace was denied the right to vote. That provides an important context, does it not?
Oh he was quackers. He almost ducked out of fighting the Armada to play with his bowls.
//That provides an important context, does it not? //

but does it justify murder, Jim?
I don't believe it justifies murder, no. It was vital and necessary to overcome apartheid. Those two statements are not contradictory.
Question Author
Jim, 16:03, ironic that the end of Apartheid was gifted the nation by a white man. FW DeKlerk agreed to dissolve the state knowing he would be deposed, that's a courageous thing to do. Now look at the state of it. Most South Africans are a lot worse off than ever before.
The should pull this statue, and others like it, down as well.

https://statues.vanderkrogt.net/object.php?webpage=ST&record=gblo076

The Knights Templar killed loads of Muslims.
What comes after they've removed the statues they don't like? Paintings, books, films, photographs, ancient maps, everything connected with slavery? Is this the start of whitewashing history?
Something I wasn't previously aware if: Francis Drake was on the ship that marked Britain's first involvement in the slave trade. Make of that what you will.
Question Author
sounds like Fahrenheit 451!
Question Author
he was on the ship? Cadging a lift?
He was Purser on a ship with his second cousin Sir John Hawkins.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Drake#Career_at_sea
// Now look at the state of it. Most South Africans are a lot worse off than ever before. //

In the sense of not being able to vote, not being able to live where they choose, marry whom they choose, go where they choose and so on? There is no doubt a long way to go to overcome the high homicide rate, and other factors, but a democratic country facing serious challenges is still preferable to a racist state.

1 to 20 of 53rss feed

1 2 3 Next Last

Do you know the answer?

Sadiq Khan Sets Up A Commision For Vandalising London...

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.