Donate SIGN UP

New Minder

Avatar Image
BertiWooster | 22:11 Wed 04th Feb 2009 | News
19 Answers
So what did you think of the new Minder sequel ?

For me the story line and the new Arthurs' dialogue was more or less similiar to that in the original .
However I didn't find the new arthur character , as funny as the original . Do you agree ?

And that is the problem - comparisons are always going to be made .



Gravatar

Answers

1 to 19 of 19rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by BertiWooster. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
I watched it with an open mind and was relieved there was no reference to Arfur and Terry.

I found it enjoyable and will watch it again, see how it shapes up.
Damn, I meant to watch that
I didn't see it,but did you realise that Lex Shrapnel (Jamie Collins) is the maternal grandson of Deborah Kerr?
His father John Shrapnel was married to Deborah Kerr's daughter Francesca Bartley.
I saw an interview with Shane Ritchie and he said it is meant to be different. He isn't playing Arthur, he is his nephew, and it is to be seen as just that.
What are they going to do the other weeks? It's all about pulling a scam, dodging and diving - a pair of crooks with hearts of gold ( saving kids from burning houses)..yadda yadda yadda....Poor relations in every sense. But it could grow on you.
I did think that it had very similar story lines and it looked like the great metrolops has not moved on in 20 years. Well the gangsters still wear shiny suits and the place looked dull and dreary. But it was pleasant enough I guess.
Question Author
I suppose it could grow on me - fair enough , give it a chance .

Yes Mr Veritas - I did know ( albeit since yesterday morning ) - when they were interviewed on b/fast tv .
I say Berti, I think this show is for the young whipper snappers and what not.
These rogueish rapscallion scoundrels and their misadventures, all in good jest.
I have to confess that I did'nt see it as I was watching a game of association football on the other channel, I forget the result...
As i has the minder name and theme, I can't help but draw comparisons with the original, which I loved (for a few years anyway), so I didn't event attempt to watch it. Sorry, Shane ritchie does nothing for me, and from what I saw in the trailers, is just an Alfie Moon clone.

Even tho it was a repeat, I watched Dennis in new tricks instead.
Question Author
What ho - Everton

Association Football ? - Oh , that game you chaps refer to as soccer
I cant wait for the polo season to start - hey what
From the advert it looked a bit too slap-stick for my tastes.
I watched a thoroughly enjoyable programme about one of my favourite authors (Terry Pratchett) instead.

If feedback is good, I may give it a chance in future.
Was all this in the news? I would have thought it belonged in Media & TV,

Oh! and the reference to Everton and Polo belongs in Sport.

Just thought I would mention it, because had I had done likewise I am sure someone would have been all too quick to point it out to me.
What o Berti, I say AOG you really are an old stick in the mud at times.
I say Berti old bean you're still infactuated with our colonial cousins, soccer I say!
Poor show.
But Polo on the green sounds elfabuloso, I'll bring the Pimms and you bring Stiffy.
Tinkerty tonk.
Question Author
Sounds spiffing - i'll bring along that gal, bobbie , as well .

Oh - I do hope Aunt Agatha isn't going to be there !!
Its hardly news as AOG says.
Question Author
So - call in the news police then
Yes, Agatha would be sure to poop on any party one cares to mention, I say!
Is that a knock at the door?
You'd better hide, it may be the news police.
I say, shall we start posting questions about health,science,shopping,food + drink etc here? What jolly japes eh?
The answer I gave when you queried whether a previous question of mine titled, 'Premature ejection' was News.

It is Berti if you follow the news.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/media/tv-rad io/itv-says-sorry-for-own-goal-as-search-for-t he-culprit-begins-1547659.html

1 to 19 of 19rss feed

Do you know the answer?

New Minder

Answer Question >>