Times "Where am I"

[mazza11]

Think answers are in the Aberdeen area. Can't identify the 2nd castle or gardens, but know they're in the area. Help

[over18]

Garden is: Mibac
Castle is: Fraser

[sir.prize]

over18 - wrong

[Lakitu]

It's not wrong, SP

[cheaton]

yes it is!

[sir.prize]

I won't argue Lakitu - but my answer is different.

[Lakitu]

What was your answer?

[cheaton]

if you google aberdeenshire gardens the answer is there!

[sir.prize]

I prefer to give additional clues rather than answers. Why make it easy for the lazy ones? After all - it is a competition of skill and rivalry.

[cheaton]

hear hear SP

[over18]

So saying I'm wrong is giving a clue is it SP?

[Lakitu]

HAHAHAHAHA!!

Well, the Q I answered this morning I answered correctly, but the question author was out by quite a number of miles! They said it was 5 miles out of Kemnay, which is nowhere near where the answer is!

Kemnay is furthest North and the answer is furthest South.

Do I still get brownie points for giving a correct answer even if the Q was wrong?? ;o)

[Catron]

You could say that about EVERY question posted in this section of the site - what makes this any different? The answer given by another poster was pitmedden garden.

[sir.prize]

over18: No, it was not a clue.

You made a statement. I made a statement in response.

No-one asked for a clue.

[Lakitu]

Pitmedden? I thought we were talking about a castle here?

[over18]

No,the garden is definitely Mibac.

[Catron]

I am just passing on what somebody else thinks:

http://www.theanswerbank.co.uk/Quizzes-and-Puz zles/Question595606.html

[sir.prize]

Lakitu - the question author does NOT say the garden is located 5 miles from anywhere

[Lakitu]

So my Castle answer is correct?

[sir.prize]

Catron - you and a few others are destroying the whole essence of competitions.

It would be SO much better if you gave additional subtle clues rather than post the exact answers. Particularly as the competition does not close for more than two full days.

Note: competition = to strive together but against one another.

[over18]

SP - you gave Arkitex the answers early last week!