Apology accepted. Going back to your post of yesterday, no I would not but Butchers, Butchers Arms, and Butchers Inn as 3 different answers to one question. With cryptic clues you cannot do it. Only when the questions are simple such as the example I gave do I put two answers. Another example of this is question no. 8 Robin Hood in this one. A very simple statement, nothing cryptic, but theoretically you could find Robin Hood in The Oaktree, The Lincoln Green and The Sherwood Forrester- he hid in the Major Oak tree in Sherwood Forest, he lived in Sherwood Forest and he wore Lincoln Green. How can Mr Lyall mark any one of them incorrrect? But if you have put only one and it is different to the one he has, then he will mark it wrong and you will not be a happy bunny. However I will only be putting down the 2 of them that are in Lincs. If he had marked me wrong for putting 2 answers such as this then I would not have continued to do it. No question setter is infallible and it may be that when he sets the simple questions he does not think that more than one answer could be the correct one. Just an observation, and I hope this clarifies it. I would never put more than one answer to a cryptic clue or when I just could not decide which was the correct one, that would make it pointless in doing the quiz in the first place.