Good Morning Late Wednesday Birds.
ChatterBank8 mins ago
Anyone seen it?
I was planning to go this weekend but there are some bad critic reports,so i thought i would ask the normal people lol.
No best answer has yet been selected by stevie-p. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.I thought it was good, but that you had to have read the book to understand some of it and how it all fitted together. There was also a bit at the end that I don't remember from the book, where Sophie meets all the people (if that gives too much away then I apologise wholeheartedly). And I've lent the book to my mum and she won't give it back, so I can't check it!
xx
I found it incredibly boring - I had read the book and found it to be entertaining but criticized it for the bad writing and reading like scenes from a film; from this i imagined that it would make a good film but it was really dull.
Can't really put my finger on why, it stuck to the original story (ending is different) the acting was pretty average etc but it seemed to go on forever, it didn't stir any emotion in me - i didn't come out thinking it was exciting or annoyed that it wasn't - it was just ok!
Save yourself the �7
I had NOT read the book, and knew little about it.
I went to see the film Sunday and came out after about 30 minutes.
I have now bought the book and started to read it and some of the things I saw in the film are begining to make sense.
** POSSIBLE SPOILER **
Only read if you have seen the film.
One of the reasons I came out is because of 2 things that happened in the first 30 minutes.
First, when the professor is signing books in the bookshop surrounded by the public he is approached by a policeman and in full view of the public shows him a picture of the dead body and asks if he will come and have a look.
Would this really happen in a bookshop at a book signing !
Secondly, when he pretends to escape from the Lourve all the police shoot off in their cars to look for him. They leave nobody by the body and nobody in the Lourve (even though the murderer may still be there).
The professor is left to look at the body and touch things with nobody there to stop him, also to wander round the Lourve looking at and even touching paintings. As if.
i really liked it...and it is a good adventure story.. as long as you take it with a huge pinch of salt!! i think the critics were too quick to judge it...but on the whole i really enjoyed it...apart from the albino monk...my god that guy freaked me out!!! i kept hiding under my jacket!!! scardey i know
p.s tom hanks looks very cute in it!!
xx
I have seen the film but not read the book(a deliberate move on my part so as not to spoil the film).I would now say that this is very important as it would have taken a lot away from the movie.
Its a good movie,not great but certainly not worthy of its mauling by the critics or leaving after only 30 mins(a bit of over analysis going on there - no offence(i do it too but take some things with a pinch of salt)!
If this was on sky,it would get a 3 star rating.