Pink Floyd without Roger Waters

[Qmark78]

Can anybody truly say the stuff they came out with without waters was worthy of the Pink Floyd name (Momentary Lapse Of Reason The Division Bell)?

[ecoman]

In my opinion, "Take it Back" off Division bell was one of the best tracks that Floyd have done without Waters, although obviously not in the same league as the older stuff.

[Qmark78]

That is a good number actually its in my ITunes

[andy-hughes]

This is always a tricky question - at what point does a b and cease to be a band and become a few people who used to be in the band, with a few others?

In Pink Floyd's case, I think the band without Roger Waters have done some excellent work, and it's a shame that differences can't be put aside for them to reunite.

The status now is that Gilmour and Waters are both touring, but neither can use the name! Gilmour and Mason own the name between them, so Gilmour is 'The Voice Of Pink Floyd' and Waters, with mason in his band is 'The Genius Behind Pink Floyd'.

I think both have valid claims to the work they produced together, and will be interested to see both performances.

I am forever sad that I will probably never see the DSPTM line-up perform again.

[andy-hughes]

Sorry - that's DSOTM - I'm not awake yet!

[Qmark78]

Live 8 was bizarre i think deep down they have a mutual respect for each other aswell as total hatred

[devilhunter]

High Hopes from the Divison Bell is just great.