Are Electric Vehicles Any More Environmentally Friendly Than I C E Ones?

ToraToraTora | 10:30 Sun 30th Jul 2023 | Motoring

35 Answers

Electricity is still generated by fossil fuels and then there is the huge amount of pollution in the manufacturing process etc.Then of course there is the huge problem with them spontaneously combusting. I sometimes wonder if this obsession with EVs is like the Emperor's new clothes. Discuss.

Electric Vehicles Can Explode Says Jeremy Clarkson

Noise When Driving Any Direction Other Than Straight Ahead.

Answers

21 to 35 of 35

First Previous 1 2

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by ToraToraTora. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.

douglas9401

"...no one actually said it but the whole bandwagon implies it."

Oh Tora, if only that kind of thinking extended to spraff on the side of buses. :-)

Gromit

We are currently generating 18% of our electric from imported coal.
We live on an island of coal but it is too expensive to extract apparently.

barry1010

There is going to be a new deep coal mine in Cumbria, believe it or not for the steel industry.
Something seems out of kilter.

ToraToraTora

Question Author

gromit: "We live on an island of coal but it is too expensive to extract apparently. " - not too expensive, too politically difficult.

ToraToraTora

Question Author

don't tell me you are suffering from RBID doug!

Ryzen

I believe ferry companies are getting twitchy about carrying EV's due to the fire risk...will this soon include Eurotunnel?

Zacs-Master

The ferry companies and Euro tunnel should acquaint themselves with the statistics then. See Gromit's earlier post.

ToraToraTora

Question Author

ZM: "The ferry companies and Euro tunnel should acquaint themselves with the statistics then. See Gromit's earlier post. " - yes non electric cars do catch fire but not spontaneously and they are not impossible to extinguish. A ferry full of ICE cars would have no fuel in them and would not catch fire, well not by the cars anyway. Did you read about the Rimac fire? It burned for days and could not be extinguished by any normal means. But frankly that's least of their problems.

douglas9401

I doubt the political difficulties outweigh the problems of getting folk to go underground after the treatment meted out to miners by Thatch and her stormtroopers, Tora.

As for the bus, you obviously want it all ways, like a good Tory.

ToraToraTora

Question Author

all ways? I can readme old china and Labour closed more mines than TGL.

douglas9401

Going to leave this one for someone trained in dealing with the bewildered, I could just make his condition worse.

ToraToraTora

Question Author

have a day off you plonker.

douglas9401

0 - 1 FT

Gromit

// not too expensive, too politically difficult. //

Labour shut the last coal mine.
The truth is that importing coal is cheaper than digging for it ourselves.
Thatcher knew that and had no qualms about shutting mines. That is an economic reality. So it is highly irritating when people moan we are importing our energy.

Stableford