­
'I'd Know If It Was Not You.' in The AnswerBank: ChatterBank
Donate SIGN UP

'I'd Know If It Was Not You.'

Avatar Image
Tilly2 | 16:55 Sat 18th Jan 2025 | ChatterBank
39 Answers

Earlier today, I went to collect some laundry from the baskets. Walking downstairs, with an arm ful of Mr T's clothes, I thought, I'd recognise that smell anywhere.

Suddenly, into my head popped a woman's lovely, sad voice saying, 'I'd know if it was not you.'

Now, I can't get rid of the voice, neither can I grasp where I've heard that before.

Anyone recognise that quote?

Gravatar
Rich Text Editor, the_answer

Answers

21 to 39 of 39rss feed

First Previous 1 2

Avatar Image
Just found this"I'd know if it was not you” is a quote from East of Eden by John Steinbeck. 
17:26 Sat 18th Jan 2025

Just put quite in Google, Tilly. 

Explanation

In East of Eden, Adam says, “I'd know if it was not you” in response to someone saying they didn't love their father. Adam is trying to understand why the person has faith in their father if they didn't love him. 

Question Author

I can't find the actual quote, Patsy.

Maybe my subconcious will unearth the woman's voice, eventually.

Thank you for looking, all of you and thank you for your search, Patsy.

I didn't find it either.  Clever patsy.  Odd that the line is spoken by a man - but you heard a woman's voice.

Made me smile, Tilly, recognising MrTs laundry smell anywhere, I completely get that.

I open OH wardrobe and his comes gently wafting out. I don't think it's aftershave, and it's definitely not a bad smell, it's just him.

Question Author

Yes, maybe it was from the film, Naomi. I've no idea. It's driving me mad though. 🙃

Vagus, I read somewhere that a woman can pick her husband's shirt out of miscellaneous pile of laundry.

A bit like Lassie!

 

Thanks Tilly.

Yes, the only thing like Naomi said, it should be a man's voice! You might eventually twig who/why it was a woman's voice one day Tilly 😀

anyway I'm off to the Land of Nod! 🤣

Question Author

Sleep well, Dave. Maybe you'll dream up the answer.

Ouch!  This has reminded me of bumping into an ex lover a few months after we had broke up and he hugged me and said oh I've so missed the smell of you.

Yikes ladybirder, that's is bit, err, odd.....

Question Author

Not odd, Vagus. Just perceptive of him.

It was meant nicely Vagus.  This was over 40 years ago and he still reacts if mutual friends mention anything not good happening in my life. Things like being suspected of having lung cancer and worse.

Sorry Tills, gone off subject.

He must have been very fond of you ladybirder ❤️

That is lovely LB, of course smells can be so evocative of the past and not always in a nice way. A whiff of Lynx Africa and I'm reminded of a world of wretched heartache :-)

Question Author

You don't need to apologise, LB. This is Chatterbank after all.

Question Author

You got involved with a man who wore Lynx aftershave, Prudie?

That sounds like a big mistake.

It was all the rage in the 90s Tilly and there is no getting away from it, it's a very sexy smell even if it is trashy.

Question Author

That's what the overpowering smell was in the boys' changing room!

What is it about Lynx aftershave that I don't know?  Don't use it myself!

21 to 39 of 39rss feed

First Previous 1 2

Do you know the answer?

'I'd Know If It Was Not You.'

Answer Question >>
Complete your gift to make an impact