Body & Soul0 min ago
The right to refuse
Can a businessman, a shopkeeper, hotel owner etc refuse to provide a service without giving a reason?
Answers
1 to 8 of 8
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by swl. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
The simple answer to your question is 'Yes'.
A shopkeeper can, for example, refuse to sell you something without telling you why. He can also decide to charge you 100 times the cost that all his other customers pay; again, he doesn't have to tell you why.
The only time when such actions would be illegal would be where the reasons (whether stated or not) breached anti-discrimination legislation, e.g. on the grounds of the customer's race.
Chris
A shopkeeper can, for example, refuse to sell you something without telling you why. He can also decide to charge you 100 times the cost that all his other customers pay; again, he doesn't have to tell you why.
The only time when such actions would be illegal would be where the reasons (whether stated or not) breached anti-discrimination legislation, e.g. on the grounds of the customer's race.
Chris
Thanks for the response, swl.
As Oneeyeevic states, it's illegal to discriminate on certain grounds but proving it is another matter. The hotelier might, for example, say 'Yes, I discriminated against that black guy but my discrimination wasn't based on any illegal criteria. It's just that I always refuse to accept bookings from people with a public school accent". That would be perfectly legal.
Chris
As Oneeyeevic states, it's illegal to discriminate on certain grounds but proving it is another matter. The hotelier might, for example, say 'Yes, I discriminated against that black guy but my discrimination wasn't based on any illegal criteria. It's just that I always refuse to accept bookings from people with a public school accent". That would be perfectly legal.
Chris
It's a civil matter. Cases of (alleged) discrimination, other than those related to employment, are heard before the county courts:
http://www.cre.gov.uk/legal/complaint.html
If the police were asked to attend an incident where racial discrimination was alleged, they might choose to do so in order to prevent a possible breach of the peace. If they did attend, it's likely that the officers would remind the service provider of the provisions of the the law. However, there is no actual obligation upon the police to attend an incident or to advise the service provider about the law. Further, neither the police nor the Crown Prosecution Service can take any direct action in relation to allegations of racial discrimination.
It's extremely difficult to prove an allegation of racial discrimination based upon a single incident. It's not illegal to refuse to serve a black man. It's only illegal to refuse to serve a man because he is black. If the service provider declines to give a reason for refusing service, proving discrimination only really becomes possible if his reasons become clear through repeated breaches of the legislation.
Chris
http://www.cre.gov.uk/legal/complaint.html
If the police were asked to attend an incident where racial discrimination was alleged, they might choose to do so in order to prevent a possible breach of the peace. If they did attend, it's likely that the officers would remind the service provider of the provisions of the the law. However, there is no actual obligation upon the police to attend an incident or to advise the service provider about the law. Further, neither the police nor the Crown Prosecution Service can take any direct action in relation to allegations of racial discrimination.
It's extremely difficult to prove an allegation of racial discrimination based upon a single incident. It's not illegal to refuse to serve a black man. It's only illegal to refuse to serve a man because he is black. If the service provider declines to give a reason for refusing service, proving discrimination only really becomes possible if his reasons become clear through repeated breaches of the legislation.
Chris
1 to 8 of 8
