Thanks Cruci for your gentle hint above ... just enough for a nudge in the right direction, still took me some time. As for the conflicting opinions, I apologise if I have offended anyone by ever requesting or offering help re the Listener - did not realise there were such raw nerves out there. However, I have to come down in favour of the exchange of ideas / hints ... I'm a great believer in the TV remote control / on/off switch - if you don't like it, don't watch. I suspect that most partaking here will only resort to seeking help having exhausted much time and effort in trying to help themselves - there is after all some pride at stake, and yes it is stepping down a peg to admit that assistance would be welcome. As Quizmonster so correctly observes, not all of the Listener contestants will be one-man bands. Those of us not fortunate enough to have an extra brain to pick at home do occasionally welcome the opportunity to find a helping hand elsewhere. Let's face it, this crossword is a great institution, but let's not spoil the enjoyment by bickering over its sanctity - if these threads are not for you, then maybe you don't need to be reading them?