I have to agree with those who say go for the safe option. I'm not 40 yet (getting there though - just turned 32) and I hate getting crappy gifts which I have no use for. I remember a few years ago, dreading what my boss was going to buy for me as I saw him pull my name out of the hat and he was renowned for being a clown basically, always larking about. As I unwrapped my present, I was filled with dread at what he may have bought me but I was delighted to have been given a lovely little Royal Jelly bath set from Boots. I love the smell of Royal Jelly products and it contained moisturising bath creme, foaming bubble bath and a body lotion. Much nicer to get things you can either eat, drink or pour in your bath and I defy any woman not to like nice smelling things for her bath. The safest option is less likely to have people taking about you for all the wrong reasons. Novelty gifts only really work if you know for definite that the person will appreciate the joke and that's just it, it's a novelty item. What happens when the novelty wears off? What does she have left to show for it?