Daffy they are great! I had a quick look on there yesterday but didn't see them thanks :o )
I'm going to be really fussy here but if the 1st one had buttons it would be prefect!...although I do really like it but I like the 2nd one too i cant decide!
I love the first one,I have had my eye on it for a week or so but can't really justify spending that much on a mac when I actually need a warmer winter coat.:-)
I like them both but prefer the first,the wide belt would help accentuate my waist(i'm a very slim size 8 with virtually no waist/hips),it may not look good on a much larger lady.The second one is a little chavvy(Burberry style check belt) but not too bad :-) I would wear either but the first is much more stylish in my opinion.