Donate SIGN UP

Have you got vs do you have?

Avatar Image
Miss Zippy | 16:25 Wed 02nd Mar 2005 | Phrases & Sayings
11 Answers
It seems that a lot of the time when you word 'got' is used, it's unnecessary, e.g. "I have got a/ I have a".  Is there any rule as to when the word 'got' should be used?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 11 of 11rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Miss Zippy. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Most such structures are informal ones originally used in American English. I should start worrying about it, Miss Z, only if you hear Brits beginning to use their past participle 'gotten'!
Question Author
Thanks QM.  I'll stop worrying :o)
My goodness...that was quick, Miss Z! Just an additional point. We started using these mainly because of our tendency to elide structures such as 'I have' into 'I've'. 'Got' was handy in order to avoid sillinesses such as 'I've it' instead of 'I have it.'

Also: have got (to + infinitive) = must

e.g., I have got... to see, go, write

Just realised that my answer didn't really answer yours...

I suppose "got" really is just extra baggage!

Question Author

I was just going to point that out in your particular example ah9815!  Thanks though.

Cheers Miss Zippy. One last instance where "got" can be used is to mean "to become", e.g., "he got ill".

I was taught that it's the difference between owning and obtaining.

I have brown hair.

I have got some of those trousers now.

Or in American:

I've gotten some of those pants now.

'Gotten' may be American now but it used to be English - same as 'forgotten' still is. They're consistent, we're not (not that consistency ever has much to do with the use of language).

Virtually the only time 'gotten' is used in modern British English usage is in the phrase 'ill-gotten gains'. As Jno's answer suggests, however, 'gotten' predated 'got' by about two centuries.

1 to 11 of 11rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Have you got vs do you have?

Answer Question >>