ChatterBank1 min ago
She is the cat's mother - origin
2 Answers
What is the origin of the above phrase and why did come into use as a rebuke regarding being polite?
I know it fis airly old as grand mother used to say it but I never did understand the origin.
Thanks
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by barmy. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.I'd guess it came from too far back in time to establish an actual original usage. The meaning, though, as you suggest, is that when someone - usually an adult speaking to a child - says, "Who's �she', the cat's mother?", it is an indication that the adult feels the child is being disrespectful.
Instead the child should have said 'Your friend' or 'Auntie Edna' or whatever else would have fitted the situation rather than just the unspecific word 'she'. In other words, one might call a cat or its mother 'she' but one shouldn't call one's elders and betters by that dismissive name.
Instead the child should have said 'Your friend' or 'Auntie Edna' or whatever else would have fitted the situation rather than just the unspecific word 'she'. In other words, one might call a cat or its mother 'she' but one shouldn't call one's elders and betters by that dismissive name.
Click here for some confirmation, though there is more specific gen about its age.