Why is Gary Barlow???

[puddicat]

This guy is a wonderful singer and songwriter he doesnt need the rest!!!

[cazzz1975]

I like both robbie and gary, both very talented guys and more importantly good golfers

[legendis.god]

gotta say i found robbie very good at the swing


and i enjoy whatever songs he sings


but hey

i might be wrong


i possibly am


but if being wrong gets him 80 million , well im sure its a mistake he can bear : 0)

[unrulyjulie]

Robbie does swing amazingly.Swing when yiyre winning is one of my favourite cds! Dont get me wrong, Robbie has a huge talent but so does Gary too! I hate when Gary is slagged off cause he is a fantastic songwriter. Take that would not be as hugely popular if it wasnt for his great songs. A beautiful world is a fantastic CD!

[Drisgirl]

puddi hasnt yet learned the ethos of CB/AB -it can in fact be a site where you can give YOUR opinions without being continually shouted down by someone who only has one.

Gawd give me strength.

In the words of the great Rabbie Burns 'wha dare meddle wi me' -plenty -we cant be arsed in the main

Save it puddi -from the first you posted you have never ever taken anyone elses opinion or help on board -i know at given times I can be forthritght but you are cantakerous -high 5 for maintaining it throughout your 'short' lived time on here.

[dustinmyeye]

dabees
Sat 22/11/08
20:46 Gary was and is the talent in Take That, but he wasn't able to make it on his own because he needed a sounding board and friends to assist him.

Robbie is a very very talented performer, i do enjoy him, but his talent is his ability to entertain a crowd. He was also lucky to find Guy Chambers as a co-writer.

I AGREE TOTALLY WITH DABEES.

back in the day robbie was always my favourite member ( literally ) but the band could carry on without him whereas if gary had left the band then there would be no take that. i think their amazing comeback would maybe have been different if they had split instantly when rob left but the fact they carried on for a while as a foursome then people thought of take that as just the four guys,which made their comeback easier to relate
to.

[legendis.god]

Well time will tell