Quizzes & Puzzles1 min ago
Unpaid Brewery Bill
10 Answers
Whilst working as a barman I signed for a brewery delivery as the owner was on holiday. This bill did not get paid and since then the owner of the pub has gone bankrupt. The brewery sold this on to a debt collection agency who have been chasing me for payment of this bill (�1,500). I agreed to pay them by installments as they threatened me with legal action as I was the one who signed and I was liable. The owner of the pub told me it should have been written off when he went bankrupt.
Is it worth me seeking legal advice about this?
Is it worth me seeking legal advice about this?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by StressedAndy. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.There's no point seeking legal advice because such advice is only necessary when there are potential grey areas. Your case is clear cut: YOU DO NOT OWE A SINGLE PENNY..
Here's an analogy:
An airline takes delivery of a new Boeing 787 airliner. Before it's officially 'signed for' it has to undergo a large number of tests but eventually the airline's head engineer is satisfied with the quality and signs the document formally taking delivery of the aircraft. The following day, before Boeing has been paid, the airline goes bust. Would you really expect the guy who signed for the aircraft to have to pay the 130 million dollar bill? If the law worked that way, nobody would ever sign for anything on behalf of their employer!
You were acting as the publican's agent, not signing on your own behalf. The debt is (or was) the publicans, not yours. The brewery should have petitioned the receiver for payment. (The chances are that they'd have either got nothing or just a tiny percentage of what was owed to them, but that's got nothing to do with you).
Tell the debt collection agency that you don't owe them anything and you're not paying them anything.
Chris
Here's an analogy:
An airline takes delivery of a new Boeing 787 airliner. Before it's officially 'signed for' it has to undergo a large number of tests but eventually the airline's head engineer is satisfied with the quality and signs the document formally taking delivery of the aircraft. The following day, before Boeing has been paid, the airline goes bust. Would you really expect the guy who signed for the aircraft to have to pay the 130 million dollar bill? If the law worked that way, nobody would ever sign for anything on behalf of their employer!
You were acting as the publican's agent, not signing on your own behalf. The debt is (or was) the publicans, not yours. The brewery should have petitioned the receiver for payment. (The chances are that they'd have either got nothing or just a tiny percentage of what was owed to them, but that's got nothing to do with you).
Tell the debt collection agency that you don't owe them anything and you're not paying them anything.
Chris
Hi Dot
I'm hoping that by telling the idiotic wally, who's trying to chase Andy for payment, that he'll get no money, will result in the matter being passed to someone more senior. That person ought to realise that it would be totally pointless taking court action against Andy.
However, if the matter did come before a court, Andy could attend with complete confidence in the validity of his case. (The 'Woolwich' once told me that they were going to court to get a repossession order for my house, because I'd allegedly not kept up my mortgage payments. I wasn't in the least bit worried because I'd got the receipt which showed that I'd paid off the mortgage in full several months earlier! We never got to court because I made the Woolwich see sense. Andy's case is every bit as strong as mine was).
Chris
I'm hoping that by telling the idiotic wally, who's trying to chase Andy for payment, that he'll get no money, will result in the matter being passed to someone more senior. That person ought to realise that it would be totally pointless taking court action against Andy.
However, if the matter did come before a court, Andy could attend with complete confidence in the validity of his case. (The 'Woolwich' once told me that they were going to court to get a repossession order for my house, because I'd allegedly not kept up my mortgage payments. I wasn't in the least bit worried because I'd got the receipt which showed that I'd paid off the mortgage in full several months earlier! We never got to court because I made the Woolwich see sense. Andy's case is every bit as strong as mine was).
Chris
I suggest you inform the police, (get a URN no. from the police for your records & proof of complaint) that you are being harrassed by debt collectors with whom you have no debt. Tell the police the debt is with your employer.
Inform the debt collector, by letter, that you have contacted the police, quoting the police URN No.
Inform the debt collector, by letter, that you have contacted the police, quoting the police URN No.
Thanks for all your great advice. Yes Oneeyedvic, I have paid them, about �400 so far. They sent me a letter a couple of weeks ago wanting a payment review that's when I thought I'd query it on here. Got no intention of giving anymore of my money to them, the thieving gits! What are the chances of me getting this money back and does anyone know how I go about this? Or should I just leave it/ignore them and put it down to experience?!
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.