Atom Heart Mother: Ultimate Critical Review

[roosi]

Huge Pink Floyd fan, got most albums, DVD's and merchandise, does anyone know if this DVD is any good? Just ordered it up......

Thanks
R

[Davethedog]

If your a massive fan shouldn't you know?

[roosi]

Erm......not if I haven't seen it before?

I am asking the question as I have bought it on a whim and want a recommendation or 2?

[VHG]

Well if you have already ordered it why will any reviews we give make any difference.

[Davethedog]

Ok Floyd have always been a strange band some things they do are stupendous and others are incredibly self indulgent and dare I say boring.

Have a look at this it sums it up:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atom_Heart_Mother

However no criticism should sway you, as you will form your own opinion.

Its a brave person who buys without listening, some of the worst albums I ever bought were because I bought on spec :-)

If you like early Floyd - you should be ok, though its not one of my favorites.

I hope you enjoy.

[VHG]

Davethedog, he is not asking about the actual Atom Heart Mother album.

He is asking about the DVD called - Atom Heart Mother: Ultimate Critical Review.

If he read some of the reviews on the amazon web site he may wish he had not bought it.

[roosi]

That's what I was asking, as some of the interviews and DVD's about them seem to be repeated, AHM is one of my favourite albums, so anything new on this album would be of benefit to me although if VHG you state that I might wish I hadn't bought it, I actually don't have time to go and read reviews, was hoping someone here could tell me what it's about briefly so I know what to expect - and if it's rubbish why?

It's for my OH's birthday and we as I say have everything else on them, I thought this would be a bit different and jut add to our / his collection.

[Davethedog]

doh!!