I would definitely shop around and i bet that if you approach your company, advising them you have got a better quote elsewhere, their price will plummet. I did this quite innocently i.e. just rang to say I wouldn't be renewing and they dropped the price, offered me vouchers and allsorts. Game of cat and mouse! I am with M&S now ((no gimmicks, just (to my surprise) came up with v.g. quote)) and cost went up by £1 a month when I renewed. I know someone who insures via the bank and pays 4 yes 4 times as much as I do!