Quizzes & Puzzles4 mins ago
Question re admissibility of audiotape evidence by the defence
1 Answers
Could anyone enlighten me on the rules of admissibility of audiotape evidence by the defence in a criminal trial? I know that the rules for the prosecution to submit audio evidence are very strict, but are they exactly the same for the defence? Scenario below….
If Person A has made an allegation of assault by Person B, with person C as the lone bystander, can Person B be allowed to submit an audio recording that was supposedly made at the time of the incident as evidence in their defence? The recording was made covertly, probably on a mobile phone, if indeed it is genuine. I presume B would be required to prove the genuineness of the recording. Would it be enough for B’s assertion of the genuineness of the recording to be supported by C (the bystander, and a friend of B)? By the way, to add another element to this, B has been highly trained and is employed as a sound recording engineer and would thus obviously be highly skilled in editing or even possibly fabricating the recording entirely.
If B and C are the only ones attesting to the genuineness of the recording, would B’s defence have a hope in hell of getting it admitted as evidence?
If Person A has made an allegation of assault by Person B, with person C as the lone bystander, can Person B be allowed to submit an audio recording that was supposedly made at the time of the incident as evidence in their defence? The recording was made covertly, probably on a mobile phone, if indeed it is genuine. I presume B would be required to prove the genuineness of the recording. Would it be enough for B’s assertion of the genuineness of the recording to be supported by C (the bystander, and a friend of B)? By the way, to add another element to this, B has been highly trained and is employed as a sound recording engineer and would thus obviously be highly skilled in editing or even possibly fabricating the recording entirely.
If B and C are the only ones attesting to the genuineness of the recording, would B’s defence have a hope in hell of getting it admitted as evidence?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by SoPerplexed. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.