Sara, when it was 'car of the year', it was of course new, and had a lot going for it, but Italian cars age rapidly and I wouldn't want to see you throwing good money after bad. I sometimes think they are designed to run on Italian sunny, salt-free roads. Even the Ferarri isn't imune; an acquaintance has a 10 year old one which after a internal camera inspection has been found to have some rust inside the cills, replacement cost ? £8,000 + ! so you aren't alone. Though I know sometimes in these matters you have to go with your heart as well as your head, and it may be 'worth it' to you.