Question Author
Heathfield, this is precisely why I posted my question. When I took out the BT 12 month £120 landline contract, their staff pointed out that 1280 has been discontinued, as I had found out some months previously. However, other BT staff said I could comply with the minimum use stipulation by dialling 1471 and then option 3 to ring back the last caller. This would be a chargeable call and I could do this to meet the quota I had to fill. Now when I was signing up it was confirmed that the 1471 route would work. Then my latest bill (but not the first) suddenly charged me for underuse even though I had made the prerequisite calls via 1471. Now, when I called them, BT said 1471 does not qualify, and 1280 was gone a long time ago. Most importantly, when I signed up for the caller ID, I received an e-mail saying I could meet the requirement by using 1280 (i.e. now they said it worked) - this astonished the people I was talking to so they sasid they would refund the charge for underuse but that in future I would be charged. I wrote and got a telephone reply, now I was most emphatically told that 1280 still works and that the charge for underuse would stand. It is therefore entirely possible that the refund has been withdrawn and put back on my bill.
It is clear that BT will say anything to get a deal, and also anything else to levy a charge, then anything completely different again to cover their behinds when they are caught out. The contract I entered into with them has been broken (including by a higher charge rate for underuse than I was quoted initially). This is what I mean by provider's resentment of you planning your usage in a way that takes all possibilities of saving into account - they simply move the goalposts to ensure they then can levy charges. Sadly, apart from the courts there is nothing an individual can do - OFCOM will not take up individual cases, you can tell them the story but it will simply be filed. This is another example of how regulation has and is failing in Britain and the consumer is too frequently at a loss to find redress. This is not a model society.