Hi , i was in the same position only a few months ago, i too was told very similar figures to yourself, the only problem to what you are proposing to do is , you will have to provide proof of your no claims bonus to your new insurer, now this is fine if you have last years renewal notice, but if you are relying on this years renewal letter to get the premium down (for having an extra years no claims bonus, i.e in 4 weeks time) then you cant do what you are wanting to do, as the dates wont match up. what i did was to let my present insurance run out as normal (i had 12 days left to run) get my new car with the free 7 days cover of insurance , what most companies do nowadys. but this gave me the extra year no claims bonus, and no fees to pay anywhere. the only downside to my situation was that my new car was uninsured for 5 days,(it was parked up in my garage) until my new policy was in force, (this isnt allowed nowadys, i know, but it takes a few days for mid to be updated, before they send a letter out to you and this often takes 3 days to get out to you, so wasnt a problem, and to this date ive never received any letter or fine for my car being taxed and uninsured for 5 days of the year.