Hi xx cutie xx
My preference is "Collection 2000" eyeliner definer.
It has a retractable crayon inside and it is not expensive. Does not smudge either.
I like boots number 7. Although I tested a benefit kohl on my hand a while back and it came out like a liquid eyeliner and didn't smudge when rubbed so I'm thinking of investing in that next time round.
Mac powerpoint pencil. Its almost too good as it can be hard to remove when you want to!! I am an eyeliner fiend and this is my fav by far, after years of experimenting. Engraved is the name of the black one. Prussian is a great dark navy colour which is good for summer. I have v blue eyes and this really brings the colour out.