Santuary Cleansing lotion is really good. I have tried simple and it's okay but this stuff does the trick and you can rub it all over your face as a cleanser but concentrate on your eyes too. I have extremely sensitive skin arround my eyes and wear heavy mascarra and this works a treat, it's about 7 quid though but well worth it!
ooo ive got proper sensitive eyes and skin and I find the perfect one i use is a boots own brand and it is like around �1.40 or 3 for 2 usually. You can get it in cucumber or non perfumed which is what i have and it is totally sting free! If your going to try it you should also try the cleanser that goes with it! I find my skins so sensitive that theyre the only cleansers and eye makeup removers i can use and you cant go wrong for like �1.40 :D