Now this is a subject without end. I have researched it extensively, and much more reservedly and carefully as I have myself aged in the cask somewhat. I have probably tried most brands and styles of whisky, even Japanese, and am now fairly certain that though I like most of them, I have a definite penchant for just a couple of brands. Tried the highland ,lowland, coastal, inland, island, blends, single malts double aged and all the other blocks that they try to entice us with in the blurb. The buyer will have a price that they are prepared to pay before even shopping. Cheap means nasty always. Expensive, by no means guarantees quality or that it will suit you. I have found and now try to stick by it that Macallan can supply something that fits every pocket and is not going to disappoint even the most ardent of would be aficionados. It is good stuff. I am also partial to the Welsh whisky makers Penderyn, and have tried every one of their distillations. I would advise that anything that says "smokey" in it's blurb to be avoided unless you have tried it and liked it. A bottle of Macallan as a gift or a present to yourself will never fail. Where are the Scots when you need them? I know that Douglas, for sure, can advise.