Thanks for your reply.
Like most of the 'big names', Post Office Insurance is actually a brokerage. If I read the fine print on my policy I find "Issued by BISL Limited on behalf of CIS General Insurance Limited". So the policy is really with Co-operative Insurance Services.
The problem with evaluating insurance is that it's hard to do so until you have to make a claim. Apart from calling the RAC out (which is included with my cover), I've not made any claims under it. (People also tend to contribute to review websites only when things go wrong, so it's probably unsurprising that most companies have mainly bad reviews)
Here's my previous post, which you've referred to:
http://www.theanswerb...e/Question992195.html
It might be worth noting that my cover was arranged over the phone, rather than online. Try a call to 0800 783 3770. If you'd prefer to stick to online quotes, start here:
http://www2.postoffic...surance/car-insurance
Chris