X Factor Fright Night,

[PankySmooch]

should be renamed mime night.

Ok it's advertised as performing live, but none of the acts are singing live, why do the judges comment as though they are?

[shoota]

Dunno - but I'm fed up of Mel's aggressive way of speaking/shouting....

[Fusion5]

Probably because they are all rubbish.

[shoota]

Meatloaf man is doing a half decent job...

[trt]

The only good thing about it for me, is watching the half naked dancers prancing about, otherwise its time for it to be put to bed!

[B00]

They aren't singing live? Are you sure?

[shoota]

Bit like Strictly in that respect....

[PankySmooch]

Definitely not singing live, hence hardly any close ups of them unless they've got their hand and microphone up close covering their mouth

[Prudie]

That Stevie is so awful he's funny. Really enjoyed his performance, laughed all the way through. Pretty sure he wasn't miming.

[PankySmooch]

Agree with you there Prudie, that sounded so bad it had to be live!

Even The Script were miming, biggest giveaway is when they all have to use Dermot's microphone to speak after they've just sung 'live'

[Caribeing]

Even the miming is awful! No one outstanding and as usual it's all about the judges!

[Georgiesmum]

It never dawned on me that they were miming. Im really shocked.. Are you sure?

[yogasun]

I must admit I thought it was live. Where does it say it isn't? As a few of them didn't get some notes wouldn't they re-record it until they got it right if it wasn't live?

[ivor4781]

give me proof that they were miming panky ? ,it's just what you think, i know there not. if your certain they are then back it up with evidence.

[ivor4781]

panky
"Even The Script were miming, biggest giveaway is when they all have to use Dermot's microphone to speak after they've just sung 'live' ".......................
you know so very little about what your implying panky

[netibiza]

Stevi can't have been miming cos he couldn't manage the last note very well as he was crying.

[FrogNog]

They're not miming.

[PankySmooch]

The "i" on the Sky remote said, "performing live", that does not mean singing live.
A couple of the acts were caught out last night miming, it's not that difficult to tell.

Also I noticed no one was wearing a poppy last night, unusual for a 'live show'

[ummmm]

They are singing live....

[lardhelmet]

There were so many bum notes last light, wouldn't they all be using the autotune thingy to make themselves sound much better if they were able to mime?

[ivor4781]

panky
your mistaken they are live except for when the all get together for the opening song that is mimed for technical reasons the rest is live !!
but no one is going to change your blinker view on this