Donate SIGN UP

Lost: 1 Höfner Guitar

Avatar Image
Canary42 | 11:46 Sun 03rd Sep 2023 | Music
20 Answers
I'm probably going to show my ignorance here, but surely a Höfner guitar isn't unique. Why doesn't Paul just buy a replacement, he must be rich enough. Or can some kind musician enlighten me.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-66700300
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 20 of 20rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by Canary42. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Its THE guitar, not A guitar
I do not think the guitar itself is unique, but the attachment to a Beatle makes it important and valuable.
If it was attached to a Beatle it wouldn't be lost.
If you read the link, you will find out the the technical adjustments and paint job do indeed make this model unique.

Some musicians regard guitars as simply tools of the trade, like a spanner is to a plumber.

Others become deeply sentimentally attached to specific instruments, especially if they have been through formative times in a musician's career, or been used on specific landmark recordings, and in this case it's both of those.

That explains why Sir Paul probably has a warehouse full of similar basses, but not this unique one, which is why he is keen to get it back if he can.
canary: "I'm probably going to show my ignorance here" - how unusual!
TTT - // canary: "I'm probably going to show my ignorance here" - how unusual! //

That's uncalled for - you go ballistic when people are unnecessarily sarcastic and rude to you, so it's not nice to do it to others.
Canary has a go at me on nearly every thread. I'm entitled to some payback.
McCartney was always the musical and song writing talent in the Beatles.(Okay Maxwells Silver Hammer was pretty dire.)Lennon was the leader of the band.McCartney was the musical genius that made the Beatles.
ynnaf - // McCartney was always the musical and song writing talent in the Beatles.(Okay Maxwells Silver Hammer was pretty dire.)Lennon was the leader of the band.McCartney was the musical genius that made the Beatles. //

I think if you look at the list of songs that John Lennon composed - the clue is in who sang the lead vocal - you will find that the honours are pretty evenly spread in terms of writing kudos.

Like all major bands, The Beatles are a product of the individual members, and the group would not have been as it was, or as successful as it was, without the individual membership involved.

It's therefore incorrect to assign any member as the 'leader' or as the 'main songwriter' - band dynamics are far more complex and involved than that - and if you read interviews with any of the Beatles, they will confirm that fact.
TTT - // Canary has a go at me on nearly every thread. I'm entitled to some payback. //

If you are a fourth-former, then possibly, but as a mature adult, and veteran of debates on here, you know better.
@17.43.Point taken,A-H.However i still think that McCartney was the better"melodyist"in the Beatles.
im very attached to my guitars, have traded a few over the years to get the ones i have now, to lose one would erm not break my heart, but id be really p!ssed off.
ynnaf - // @17.43.Point taken,A-H.However i still think that McCartney was the better"melodyist"in the Beatles. //

I would entirely agree, and most music journalists would, and I am sure, if asked, The Beatles would as well.
fender - //
im very attached to my guitars, have traded a few over the years to get the ones i have now, to lose one would erm not break my heart, but id be really p!ssed off. //

It depends entirely on the attitude of the individual musician - as I said, for some, guitars are simply tools of the trade, for others, they are as precious as family.
It is unique, in the same way that the first car you bought is the only first car you bought and always will be.

AH: "If you are a fourth-former, then possibly, but as a mature adult, and veteran of debates on here, you know better. " - have a look at canaries idiotic comments on some of my threads, just doing what he does.
TTT - Then you know what that makes you.
Musical instruments also have a character that develops with age depending on how they're played and generally looked after so that bass will feel quite different from a modern equivalent of the same model.
Ok Andy, so canary can carp all over my threads and I'm not allowed to retaliate, right oh!
TTT - I'm not going to assist you in derailing this thread with your infantile need to defend your tit-for-tat playground nonsense.

If you want to discuss the subject at hand with me, great, but our exchange on this peripheral rubbish is now concluded.

1 to 20 of 20rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Lost: 1 Höfner Guitar

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.