Here's the full story of Pickettywitch.
Once upon a time, there was a band called the 20th Century Show Band which included Polly Brown, Chris Warren, Keith Hall and Bob (can't remember his surname). There was several others as well including a guitarist and bass player whose names I can't remember and a second girl singer.
The 20th Century Showband eventually became Pickettywitch as a 6 piece with Polly, Chris, Keith, Bob and the guitarist and bass player mentioned above.
They signed to Pye Records with John McLeod as their producer. John McLeod was one half of the McCauley/McLeod songwriting team who had written hits for the Foundations, Long John Baldry and the Paper Dolls. Tony McCauley was the creative part of this writing partnership with John McLeod providing the musical input (i.e. he played the piano). When Tony left Pye to go off and be creative with other writers, John stepped into his shoes as a producer.
Pickettywitch released a single which disappeared without trace but they had a contract which said that Pye had to release 3 singles in the first year so their manager, David Cardwell, pressed John McLeod to produce a second single.
John looked around for a song he had written previously with Tony because it would be good for his bank balance and came up with That Same Old Feeling which had been released previously on a Foundations LP.
No one expected the record to be a hit but Tony Blackburn started to play it on his morning show on Radio 1 and it took off, eventually reaching No 5 in the official chart.
Meanwhile, two talented musicians (myself and my friend Brian Stuart) were entertaining revellers in a pub called the greyhound at Chadwell Heath to the east of London. We had spent some time rehearsing a band with Chris Warren before he became part of the 20th Century Showband but that band never got off the ground so we went our separate ways. <